"No one should be allowed to make music as if he were made of wood. One must reproduce the musical text exactly, but not play like a stone"
About this Quote
Messiaen’s jab lands because it’s aimed at a very specific modern disease: the sanctification of “fidelity” until performance becomes taxidermy. The line is built on a delicious contradiction that isn’t really a contradiction at all. “Reproduce the musical text exactly” is the conservatory mantra, the moral alibi of the dutiful interpreter. Then he flips it: exactness without animation is its own kind of betrayal. Wood, stone: he isn’t just calling out stiffness, he’s calling out a spiritual deadness that can hide behind correct notes and clean rhythm.
The subtext is theological as much as musical. Messiaen, the Catholic mystic of birdsong and blazing harmonies, treats a score less like a blueprint and more like scripture: precise in letter, alive in utterance. His music is famously detailed, loaded with tempo markings, dynamics, articulations, and color instructions that can feel like a cage to pianists and conductors. This quote is him insisting the cage was never the point. The point is incarnation: the text becomes sound only when a human body risks expression.
Context matters: 20th-century performance culture increasingly prized “objective” readings, especially as recording technology made microscopic accuracy audible and marketable. Messiaen pushes back without giving an easy escape hatch into self-indulgence. He’s not licensing sloppy rubato or personality-as-interpretation. He’s demanding a higher discipline: obey the text so completely that you’re free to be alive inside it. The stone player follows rules; the musician follows meaning.
The subtext is theological as much as musical. Messiaen, the Catholic mystic of birdsong and blazing harmonies, treats a score less like a blueprint and more like scripture: precise in letter, alive in utterance. His music is famously detailed, loaded with tempo markings, dynamics, articulations, and color instructions that can feel like a cage to pianists and conductors. This quote is him insisting the cage was never the point. The point is incarnation: the text becomes sound only when a human body risks expression.
Context matters: 20th-century performance culture increasingly prized “objective” readings, especially as recording technology made microscopic accuracy audible and marketable. Messiaen pushes back without giving an easy escape hatch into self-indulgence. He’s not licensing sloppy rubato or personality-as-interpretation. He’s demanding a higher discipline: obey the text so completely that you’re free to be alive inside it. The stone player follows rules; the musician follows meaning.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Olivier
Add to List
