"Nobody can give a good performance unless the authors and composers have written a good part, a fact which is often overlooked"
About this Quote
Star-making performances get sold as personal magic, but Holliday quietly drags the camera back to the page. Her point is almost embarrassingly practical: actors don’t levitate scenes out of sheer charisma. They’re working inside an architecture built by writers and composers, and if that structure is weak, the most skilled performer is left doing expensive interior decorating.
The bite is in “often overlooked.” Holliday isn’t scolding audiences so much as the whole machinery that treats acting like the final, decisive ingredient while relegating authorship to credits you read on the way out. In mid-century American entertainment, the performer’s face was the brand and the marketing hook; the labor behind the role was easier to erase. Holliday, who won an Oscar for Born Yesterday and came up through Broadway, knew how tightly performance is tethered to language, timing, and musical phrasing. Comedy especially is unforgiving: one missing beat, one line that doesn’t turn, and the actor becomes the person “trying” instead of the person “being.”
There’s also an ethic of craft here, not false modesty. She’s defending standards. A “good part” isn’t just flattering material; it’s playable material, with intention, rhythm, and choices embedded in it. By framing this as a “fact,” Holliday punctures the romantic myth of raw talent and replaces it with something more demanding: collaboration. The subtext is a plea for credit, yes, but also for accountability. If a performance fails, it’s not always the actor’s sin; sometimes the script is the crime scene.
The bite is in “often overlooked.” Holliday isn’t scolding audiences so much as the whole machinery that treats acting like the final, decisive ingredient while relegating authorship to credits you read on the way out. In mid-century American entertainment, the performer’s face was the brand and the marketing hook; the labor behind the role was easier to erase. Holliday, who won an Oscar for Born Yesterday and came up through Broadway, knew how tightly performance is tethered to language, timing, and musical phrasing. Comedy especially is unforgiving: one missing beat, one line that doesn’t turn, and the actor becomes the person “trying” instead of the person “being.”
There’s also an ethic of craft here, not false modesty. She’s defending standards. A “good part” isn’t just flattering material; it’s playable material, with intention, rhythm, and choices embedded in it. By framing this as a “fact,” Holliday punctures the romantic myth of raw talent and replaces it with something more demanding: collaboration. The subtext is a plea for credit, yes, but also for accountability. If a performance fails, it’s not always the actor’s sin; sometimes the script is the crime scene.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Judy
Add to List
