"Nobody ever defended anything successfully, there is only attack and attack and attack some more"
About this Quote
Patton’s line is the kind of hard-edged simplification that only makes sense when you remember what he was selling: motion as salvation. On its face, it’s a provocation - an argument against the comforting fantasy that you can hunker down, absorb punishment, and “hold” your way to victory. Patton is trying to rewire a soldier’s instincts. Defense feels prudent, even virtuous; offense feels risky. He flips that moral framing. In his worldview, defense is not restraint, it’s surrender with paperwork.
The subtext is psychological as much as tactical. “Attack and attack and attack some more” is an incantation designed to drown out fear, doubt, and the bureaucratic caution of higher command. Repetition does the work of doctrine: it makes aggression sound like inevitability rather than choice. It also turns tempo into identity - you are not a unit that waits; you are a unit that imposes.
Context matters: Patton came of age in an era when industrial war made static defense both seductive and catastrophic. The trench logic of World War I promised safety in fortifications and delivered slaughter by the yard. By World War II, speed, armor, and air power made the cost of passivity even higher; getting fixed in place invited encirclement, attrition, and the slow erosion of morale.
The intent isn’t a universal military truth - defenses can win battles. It’s leadership rhetoric, sharpened into an absolute so it can cut through hesitation. Patton isn’t describing war; he’s prescribing a mentality that turns chaos into momentum and momentum into advantage.
The subtext is psychological as much as tactical. “Attack and attack and attack some more” is an incantation designed to drown out fear, doubt, and the bureaucratic caution of higher command. Repetition does the work of doctrine: it makes aggression sound like inevitability rather than choice. It also turns tempo into identity - you are not a unit that waits; you are a unit that imposes.
Context matters: Patton came of age in an era when industrial war made static defense both seductive and catastrophic. The trench logic of World War I promised safety in fortifications and delivered slaughter by the yard. By World War II, speed, armor, and air power made the cost of passivity even higher; getting fixed in place invited encirclement, attrition, and the slow erosion of morale.
The intent isn’t a universal military truth - defenses can win battles. It’s leadership rhetoric, sharpened into an absolute so it can cut through hesitation. Patton isn’t describing war; he’s prescribing a mentality that turns chaos into momentum and momentum into advantage.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|---|
| Source | Rejected source: Notes on Bastogne Operation, 3rd U.S. Army (Patton, George S. (George Smith), 188..., 1945)IA: NotesOnBastogneOperation3rdU.s.Army
Evidence: ate offensive near saarbrucken the key to this situation is st avoid as long as we hold there and attack from there th Other candidates (2) Operation Cobra and the Great Offensive (Bill Yenne, 2010) compilation95.0% ... Nobody ever defended anything successfully . There is only attack and attack , and attack some more . -Field Mars... George S. Patton (George S. Patton) compilation34.5% field the germans were painstaking in their analysis of the leaders who faced them in battle and patton was the only |
More Quotes by George
Add to List






