"Not everybody is perfect, and I don't think we should be looking for perfect people"
About this Quote
Cowell’s brand has always been built on the paradox of being the guy who weaponizes standards while insisting he’s not selling perfection. This line is less a kumbaya plea than a tactical reframing of what “talent” TV promises: not flawless humans, but watchable ones. It gives him permission to be brutally candid while still sounding like the adult in the room.
The intent is to lower the moral temperature around judgment. In a culture that confuses critique with cruelty, Cowell positions himself as anti-idealism: don’t demand saints, don’t demand polish, don’t demand a backstory that makes you feel virtuous for watching. He’s defending messiness as a feature, not a bug. That’s useful when your entire format depends on failure, humiliation, and redemption arcs, delivered in neat weekly doses.
The subtext is also self-protective. If “perfect people” aren’t the goal, then the show’s manipulations, harsh edits, and public pile-ons can be recast as realism rather than exploitation. It’s a way to sanitize spectacle: we’re not tearing down a person, we’re stress-testing a dream.
Context matters: reality competition TV emerged as both a democratizing fantasy (anyone can be discovered) and a factory for mass judgment. Cowell, as the on-screen executioner with a punchline, needs the audience to believe they’re participating in something honest, not simply mean. By rejecting perfection, he keeps the focus where the genre thrives: on the cracked voice, the shaky confidence, the almost-there performer who makes you argue with your friends the next day.
The intent is to lower the moral temperature around judgment. In a culture that confuses critique with cruelty, Cowell positions himself as anti-idealism: don’t demand saints, don’t demand polish, don’t demand a backstory that makes you feel virtuous for watching. He’s defending messiness as a feature, not a bug. That’s useful when your entire format depends on failure, humiliation, and redemption arcs, delivered in neat weekly doses.
The subtext is also self-protective. If “perfect people” aren’t the goal, then the show’s manipulations, harsh edits, and public pile-ons can be recast as realism rather than exploitation. It’s a way to sanitize spectacle: we’re not tearing down a person, we’re stress-testing a dream.
Context matters: reality competition TV emerged as both a democratizing fantasy (anyone can be discovered) and a factory for mass judgment. Cowell, as the on-screen executioner with a punchline, needs the audience to believe they’re participating in something honest, not simply mean. By rejecting perfection, he keeps the focus where the genre thrives: on the cracked voice, the shaky confidence, the almost-there performer who makes you argue with your friends the next day.
Quote Details
| Topic | Humility |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Simon
Add to List






