"Not to help justice in her need would be an impiety"
About this Quote
Plato makes justice sound less like a courtroom principle and more like a sacred obligation: neglect it and you are not merely mistaken, you are morally profane. The word “impiety” is doing the heavy lifting. In a culture where piety indexed your relationship to the gods and the city, Plato hijacks religious vocabulary to shame political passivity. Justice is “in her need” like an abandoned dependent, feminized and vulnerable, and the citizen’s failure to act becomes a kind of sacrilege.
The intent isn’t gentle exhortation; it’s social pressure with metaphysical backup. Plato wants justice to stop being treated as a negotiable convenience - something you honor when it benefits you and ignore when it costs. By framing assistance as a duty owed to a higher order, he sidesteps the usual excuses: fear, fatigue, “not my problem.” You can’t opt out of the sacred without branding yourself as corrupted.
The subtext also reflects Plato’s larger project: tying ethical life to cosmic structure. In the Republic and related dialogues, justice isn’t just fair outcomes; it’s harmony, proper order, each part doing its work. When justice is “in need,” the world is out of joint, and indifference becomes complicity in disorder. That’s why he doesn’t say “it would be wrong” but “impious”: he’s fusing civic responsibility, personal character, and the health of the polis into one charged moral category.
Contextually, Plato is writing in the shadow of Athens’ political traumas - demagoguery, war, the execution of Socrates. “Helping justice” is not abstract virtue-signaling; it’s a rebuke to a city that watched institutions bend and called it normal.
The intent isn’t gentle exhortation; it’s social pressure with metaphysical backup. Plato wants justice to stop being treated as a negotiable convenience - something you honor when it benefits you and ignore when it costs. By framing assistance as a duty owed to a higher order, he sidesteps the usual excuses: fear, fatigue, “not my problem.” You can’t opt out of the sacred without branding yourself as corrupted.
The subtext also reflects Plato’s larger project: tying ethical life to cosmic structure. In the Republic and related dialogues, justice isn’t just fair outcomes; it’s harmony, proper order, each part doing its work. When justice is “in need,” the world is out of joint, and indifference becomes complicity in disorder. That’s why he doesn’t say “it would be wrong” but “impious”: he’s fusing civic responsibility, personal character, and the health of the polis into one charged moral category.
Contextually, Plato is writing in the shadow of Athens’ political traumas - demagoguery, war, the execution of Socrates. “Helping justice” is not abstract virtue-signaling; it’s a rebuke to a city that watched institutions bend and called it normal.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by Plato
Add to List











