"Note the three most important Cabinet positions. Rice said that it was better to find the weapons of mass destruction than to see a mushroom cloud"
About this Quote
A priest turning stenographer for the national-security state is already a provocation, and Greeley leans into it by making the line feel like a marginal note you were never supposed to read. "Note the three most important Cabinet positions" is a stage direction, not a thought: he’s cueing the audience to watch power sort itself, then naming the cast implicitly (State, Defense, Treasury; or in the post-9/11 imagination, State, Defense, and the Vice President’s shadow apparatus). The clerical voice here isn’t pious; it’s procedural, like someone circling the true levers of empire in a catechism.
Then comes Condoleezza Rice’s infamous "mushroom cloud" framing, one of the Bush era’s most efficient bits of fear rhetoric. Greeley’s intent is less to litigate the factual claim (WMD) than to expose the moral mechanics: a speculative apocalypse is used to launder preemptive war into prudence. The phrase "better to find the weapons... than to see a mushroom cloud" is a wager with asymmetrical evidence. You can always keep searching for WMD; you can never disprove the cloud that didn’t happen. It’s a logic that converts anxiety into policy and turns uncertainty into a mandate.
As a clergyman, Greeley’s subtext is indictment: a culture that treats catastrophe as a persuasive device has replaced discernment with dread. The bite isn’t in outrage; it’s in how calmly he shows the gears.
Then comes Condoleezza Rice’s infamous "mushroom cloud" framing, one of the Bush era’s most efficient bits of fear rhetoric. Greeley’s intent is less to litigate the factual claim (WMD) than to expose the moral mechanics: a speculative apocalypse is used to launder preemptive war into prudence. The phrase "better to find the weapons... than to see a mushroom cloud" is a wager with asymmetrical evidence. You can always keep searching for WMD; you can never disprove the cloud that didn’t happen. It’s a logic that converts anxiety into policy and turns uncertainty into a mandate.
As a clergyman, Greeley’s subtext is indictment: a culture that treats catastrophe as a persuasive device has replaced discernment with dread. The bite isn’t in outrage; it’s in how calmly he shows the gears.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|
More Quotes by Andrew
Add to List




