"Nothing is ever the same as they said it was"
About this Quote
Nothing is ever the same as they said it was is a photographer's manifesto disguised as a shrug. Arbus is taking aim at the whole secondhand world: the stories we inherit about people, places, even ourselves. "They" could be critics, family, polite society, the glossy magazines she once worked for - anyone invested in smoothing reality into something consumable. Her line refuses that smoothing. It insists that experience is not a caption.
The phrasing does quiet violence to expectation. "Nothing" is absolute, almost taunting, but the sentence isn't dramatic; it's flat, reportorial. That tonal mismatch is the point. Arbus isn't romanticizing truth; she's describing the everyday betrayal built into representation. "Ever" widens it into a rule of perception: time changes things, memory distorts them, and language arrives late. The past is always already edited.
Context matters because Arbus made her reputation photographing people America preferred to keep off-camera - outsiders, performers, the visibly different, the ordinary rendered strange by direct attention. Her work exposed how much of "normal" is a social agreement, not a fact. In that light, the quote reads less like pessimism than method: go look for yourself, and keep looking after the narrative claims it's settled.
Subtext: distrust the authorized version. The camera, often treated as an objective witness, becomes in Arbus's hands a tool for revealing how staged our certainties are. The sting is that she includes the viewer in "they". We are always being told what we're seeing - and we are always wrong by at least a little.
The phrasing does quiet violence to expectation. "Nothing" is absolute, almost taunting, but the sentence isn't dramatic; it's flat, reportorial. That tonal mismatch is the point. Arbus isn't romanticizing truth; she's describing the everyday betrayal built into representation. "Ever" widens it into a rule of perception: time changes things, memory distorts them, and language arrives late. The past is always already edited.
Context matters because Arbus made her reputation photographing people America preferred to keep off-camera - outsiders, performers, the visibly different, the ordinary rendered strange by direct attention. Her work exposed how much of "normal" is a social agreement, not a fact. In that light, the quote reads less like pessimism than method: go look for yourself, and keep looking after the narrative claims it's settled.
Subtext: distrust the authorized version. The camera, often treated as an objective witness, becomes in Arbus's hands a tool for revealing how staged our certainties are. The sting is that she includes the viewer in "they". We are always being told what we're seeing - and we are always wrong by at least a little.
Quote Details
| Topic | Truth |
|---|
More Quotes by Diane
Add to List
