"Nothing is inevitable until it happens"
About this Quote
History loves to cosplay as fate. Taylor’s line punctures that costume with a single, dry pinprick: inevitability is often a story we tell after the fact, not a force that drives events beforehand. Coming from a historian who made a career of provoking the pieties of his field, it’s a sly warning against the grand, complacent narrative that war, revolutions, and collapses were “bound” to occur. They weren’t bound. They were made.
The intent is methodological as much as philosophical. Taylor is pushing back on teleology: the habit of reading the past like a plot with a prewritten ending. Once the ending is known, every earlier scene gets reinterpreted as foreshadowing. Leaders become puppets, accidents get demoted to “symptoms,” and contingency vanishes. Taylor’s point is that contingency is the engine. Only after an event hardens into reality do we start pouring the concrete around it, calling it inevitable to make it feel intelligible and, sometimes, excusable.
The subtext carries a moral edge. “Inevitable” can be an alibi: no one could have stopped it, so no one is responsible. Taylor refuses that comfort. His phrasing is deliberately flat, almost bureaucratic, which is part of the wit: a profound claim delivered like common sense. It’s also a quiet provocation to the reader. If nothing is inevitable until it happens, then politics and agency matter right up to the last minute - and so do the choices we’d rather rebrand as destiny.
The intent is methodological as much as philosophical. Taylor is pushing back on teleology: the habit of reading the past like a plot with a prewritten ending. Once the ending is known, every earlier scene gets reinterpreted as foreshadowing. Leaders become puppets, accidents get demoted to “symptoms,” and contingency vanishes. Taylor’s point is that contingency is the engine. Only after an event hardens into reality do we start pouring the concrete around it, calling it inevitable to make it feel intelligible and, sometimes, excusable.
The subtext carries a moral edge. “Inevitable” can be an alibi: no one could have stopped it, so no one is responsible. Taylor refuses that comfort. His phrasing is deliberately flat, almost bureaucratic, which is part of the wit: a profound claim delivered like common sense. It’s also a quiet provocation to the reader. If nothing is inevitable until it happens, then politics and agency matter right up to the last minute - and so do the choices we’d rather rebrand as destiny.
Quote Details
| Topic | Free Will & Fate |
|---|
More Quotes by J. P. Taylor
Add to List






