"Nothing is more unreliable than the populace, nothing more obscure than human intentions, nothing more deceptive than the whole electoral system"
About this Quote
Democracy, Cicero implies, isn’t merely messy; it’s epistemologically broken. The line lands like a three-part indictment, each clause tightening the vise: the people are unreliable, motives are unreadable, elections are rigged by their very design. It’s not just pessimism. It’s a Roman statesman’s diagnosis of how public life actually operates when reputation is currency, fear is a campaign strategy, and “the will of the people” is an effect produced by theater, patronage, and rumor.
The rhetorical power comes from the anaphora of “nothing more...” a drumbeat that mimics legal argument while smuggling in a darker claim: politics is the art of navigating unknowability. Cicero isn’t saying voters are stupid; he’s saying crowds are volatile because they’re social organisms, swayed by spectacle, scarcity, and charisma. “Human intentions” being “obscure” matters even more: if you can’t read motives, you can’t trust promises, and if you can’t trust promises, elections become less a mechanism of consent than a marketplace of performances.
Context sharpens the cynicism. Cicero lived through the late Republic’s convulsions: populist demagogues, elite backroom deals, street violence, and the slow conversion of civic procedures into weapons. His own career depended on persuading assemblies while warning that assemblies could be seduced. The subtext is self-protective and elitist: a case for restraint, institutional ballast, and senatorial stewardship over mass sentiment.
It works because it’s less about hating democracy than about exposing its Achilles’ heel: legitimacy built on collective judgment, when collective judgment is the easiest thing to manufacture.
The rhetorical power comes from the anaphora of “nothing more...” a drumbeat that mimics legal argument while smuggling in a darker claim: politics is the art of navigating unknowability. Cicero isn’t saying voters are stupid; he’s saying crowds are volatile because they’re social organisms, swayed by spectacle, scarcity, and charisma. “Human intentions” being “obscure” matters even more: if you can’t read motives, you can’t trust promises, and if you can’t trust promises, elections become less a mechanism of consent than a marketplace of performances.
Context sharpens the cynicism. Cicero lived through the late Republic’s convulsions: populist demagogues, elite backroom deals, street violence, and the slow conversion of civic procedures into weapons. His own career depended on persuading assemblies while warning that assemblies could be seduced. The subtext is self-protective and elitist: a case for restraint, institutional ballast, and senatorial stewardship over mass sentiment.
It works because it’s less about hating democracy than about exposing its Achilles’ heel: legitimacy built on collective judgment, when collective judgment is the easiest thing to manufacture.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by Cicero
Add to List
