"Nothing is proved, all is permitted"
About this Quote
"Nothing is proved, all is permitted" lands like a cold splash because it refuses the comforting idea that the world is legible. Dreiser, the great American anatomist of appetite and accident, isn’t offering a party slogan for lawlessness; he’s describing a social physics he sees everywhere: in courts that bend toward money, in moral codes that harden around whoever already has power, in lives steered less by virtue than by pressure.
The first clause is the knife. "Nothing is proved" isn’t just skepticism about logic; it’s a jab at the era’s faith that science, progress, and respectable opinion will sort the good from the bad. Dreiser’s naturalism is built on the opposite premise: people do not get what they deserve, they get what circumstances allow. Proof - moral or factual - is always provisional, always vulnerable to narrative, to status, to who gets believed.
Then comes the turn that makes the line sting: "all is permitted". Not because Dreiser celebrates permission, but because he sees permission quietly granted in practice even when denied in principle. Society polices the weak with rules and indulges the strong with exceptions. The subtext is a grim kind of realism: if certainty is unavailable, ethics becomes negotiation, and power becomes the deciding evidence.
It works because it compresses an entire Dreiser novel into a sentence: a world where explanation trails after events like exhaust, and where the difference between crime and success is often just documentation, timing, and the right friends.
The first clause is the knife. "Nothing is proved" isn’t just skepticism about logic; it’s a jab at the era’s faith that science, progress, and respectable opinion will sort the good from the bad. Dreiser’s naturalism is built on the opposite premise: people do not get what they deserve, they get what circumstances allow. Proof - moral or factual - is always provisional, always vulnerable to narrative, to status, to who gets believed.
Then comes the turn that makes the line sting: "all is permitted". Not because Dreiser celebrates permission, but because he sees permission quietly granted in practice even when denied in principle. Society polices the weak with rules and indulges the strong with exceptions. The subtext is a grim kind of realism: if certainty is unavailable, ethics becomes negotiation, and power becomes the deciding evidence.
It works because it compresses an entire Dreiser novel into a sentence: a world where explanation trails after events like exhaust, and where the difference between crime and success is often just documentation, timing, and the right friends.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Theodore
Add to List





