"Nothing of the kind; they do all these things in their houses and sheds, with common charcoal fires, and a quantity of straw to stop up the crevices in the doors and windows"
About this Quote
The brisk dismissal in "Nothing of the kind" is doing more than correcting a technical misunderstanding; it performs authority. Robert Fortune, writing as a nineteenth-century plant hunter-scientist, is policing the boundary between rumor and observation, but also between "civilized" industry and the improvisational realities he encounters in China. The sentence lands like field notes with an edge: no grand furnaces, no heroic machinery, just houses, sheds, charcoal, and straw jammed into cracks. It punctures an imagined, exoticized production process by insisting on a mundane one.
That mundanity is the point. Fortune is documenting how sophisticated outcomes can come from what reads, to a British reader, as makeshift infrastructure. The subtext is double: respect for practical knowledge (these people know exactly how to control heat and airflow), and a colonial-era surprise that expertise might look unindustrial. By listing materials that feel humble - "common charcoal", "a quantity of straw" - he quietly challenges the era's assumption that progress requires visibly modern technology.
Context matters: Fortune traveled and collected botanical intelligence during a period when Britain was desperate to understand and replicate Asian agricultural and manufacturing techniques, especially those tied to valuable commodities. His specificity is a form of extraction: details about fuel, insulation, and ventilation are not just descriptive; they're transferable. The sentence reads like a recipe smuggled inside reportage, converting local craft into exportable know-how while maintaining the scientific posture of dispassionate correction.
That mundanity is the point. Fortune is documenting how sophisticated outcomes can come from what reads, to a British reader, as makeshift infrastructure. The subtext is double: respect for practical knowledge (these people know exactly how to control heat and airflow), and a colonial-era surprise that expertise might look unindustrial. By listing materials that feel humble - "common charcoal", "a quantity of straw" - he quietly challenges the era's assumption that progress requires visibly modern technology.
Context matters: Fortune traveled and collected botanical intelligence during a period when Britain was desperate to understand and replicate Asian agricultural and manufacturing techniques, especially those tied to valuable commodities. His specificity is a form of extraction: details about fuel, insulation, and ventilation are not just descriptive; they're transferable. The sentence reads like a recipe smuggled inside reportage, converting local craft into exportable know-how while maintaining the scientific posture of dispassionate correction.
Quote Details
| Topic | Travel |
|---|
More Quotes by Robert
Add to List
