"Nothing that you have not given away will ever be really yours"
About this Quote
Lewis slips a radical claim into a sentence that sounds almost like common sense: ownership is a moral mirage unless it passes through your hands and leaves them. The line works because it flips the normal hierarchy of value. We treat keeping as proof of possession; Lewis treats giving as the only reliable receipt. What you cling to remains provisional, always threatened by time, loss, death, even the internal corrosion of anxiety. What you give away becomes stable, not because it’s physically secured, but because it’s been converted into character.
The subtext is recognizably Christian and, more specifically, Lewisian: the self is not made fuller by accumulation but by surrender. He’s arguing against the modern fantasy that identity can be built like a pantry. In his world, “really yours” doesn’t mean legally owned; it means integrated into the kind of person you are. Generosity isn’t a hobby. It’s a technology for turning fleeting resources into durable spiritual assets.
Context matters. Lewis wrote in the shadow of two world wars and a shaken European confidence in permanence. In that atmosphere, hoarding looks less like prudence and more like a pact with fear. The sentence also carries his polemical edge against polite religiosity: charity isn’t an optional add-on for the virtuous; it’s the only way your life stops being a temporary rental.
There’s a quiet accusation baked in. If you’ve never given it, you never owned it; it owned you.
The subtext is recognizably Christian and, more specifically, Lewisian: the self is not made fuller by accumulation but by surrender. He’s arguing against the modern fantasy that identity can be built like a pantry. In his world, “really yours” doesn’t mean legally owned; it means integrated into the kind of person you are. Generosity isn’t a hobby. It’s a technology for turning fleeting resources into durable spiritual assets.
Context matters. Lewis wrote in the shadow of two world wars and a shaken European confidence in permanence. In that atmosphere, hoarding looks less like prudence and more like a pact with fear. The sentence also carries his polemical edge against polite religiosity: charity isn’t an optional add-on for the virtuous; it’s the only way your life stops being a temporary rental.
There’s a quiet accusation baked in. If you’ve never given it, you never owned it; it owned you.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by S. Lewis
Add to List










