"Nothing was more up-to-date when it was built, or is more obsolete today, than the railroad station"
About this Quote
A railroad station is the rare building type that arrives already aging, a monument to the present tense that can’t keep up with the next timetable. Huxtable’s line lands because it treats “up-to-date” and “obsolete” not as opposites but as a loop: the station is built to embody speed, coordination, and modern life, yet its very purpose is to serve systems that modernity constantly replaces.
The intent is diagnostic, not nostalgic. Huxtable is pointing at how architecture gets trapped between infrastructure and fashion. Stations were once civic showpieces - the grand gateway where a city staged its confidence in technology and commerce. Then the same spaces are stranded by new mobility regimes: highways, airports, decentralized commuting, real estate logic that values square footage over gathering. What was designed as an engine of movement becomes a container for waiting, then for vacancy, then for “adaptive reuse,” that polite euphemism for admitting the original cultural contract has expired.
Subtext: modernity is a churn, and buildings are the collateral damage. The station’s obsolescence isn’t just about trains losing dominance; it’s about how quickly societies abandon shared public rituals. A station concentrates strangers under one roof with a common purpose - exactly the kind of civic density late-20th-century America learned to distrust or privatize.
Context matters: Huxtable wrote as a critic watching postwar cities demolish or neuter their great terminals, mistaking inconvenience for inevitability. Her sting is aimed at the complacent idea that progress is self-evident. The station isn’t merely outmoded; it’s evidence that “the new” has a short half-life, and we build yesterday’s future with remarkable confidence.
The intent is diagnostic, not nostalgic. Huxtable is pointing at how architecture gets trapped between infrastructure and fashion. Stations were once civic showpieces - the grand gateway where a city staged its confidence in technology and commerce. Then the same spaces are stranded by new mobility regimes: highways, airports, decentralized commuting, real estate logic that values square footage over gathering. What was designed as an engine of movement becomes a container for waiting, then for vacancy, then for “adaptive reuse,” that polite euphemism for admitting the original cultural contract has expired.
Subtext: modernity is a churn, and buildings are the collateral damage. The station’s obsolescence isn’t just about trains losing dominance; it’s about how quickly societies abandon shared public rituals. A station concentrates strangers under one roof with a common purpose - exactly the kind of civic density late-20th-century America learned to distrust or privatize.
Context matters: Huxtable wrote as a critic watching postwar cities demolish or neuter their great terminals, mistaking inconvenience for inevitability. Her sting is aimed at the complacent idea that progress is self-evident. The station isn’t merely outmoded; it’s evidence that “the new” has a short half-life, and we build yesterday’s future with remarkable confidence.
Quote Details
| Topic | Time |
|---|
More Quotes by Ada
Add to List
