"Now a Protestant confronting a Catholic ghost is exactly Shakespeare's way of grappling with what was not simply a general social problem but one lived out in his own life"
About this Quote
Greenblatt’s line slips a blade between literary analysis and biography, insisting that Hamlet’s opening weirdness is not just spooky atmosphere but a confession in costume. The phrasing matters: “exactly Shakespeare’s way” is a confident, almost prosecutorial claim about authorial strategy. Greenblatt isn’t content to treat the ghost as a handy plot device; he reads it as a cultural symptom smuggled onto the stage.
The pressure point is the religious mismatch. A Protestant world is, officially, not supposed to have Catholic ghosts. Post-Reformation England tried to banish purgatory, prayers for the dead, and the entire spiritual economy that made a restless spirit legible. Yet Hamlet begins with a figure who behaves like a purgatorial messenger anyway: demanding remembrance, implying unfinished moral accounting, pulling the living into obligations the new theology says shouldn’t exist. That contradiction is the engine. It produces dread not because a ghost appears, but because the ghost’s very category is politically and doctrinally contested.
Greenblatt’s subtext is that Shakespeare stages the national argument inside a family drama: the son trapped between competing scripts for duty, mourning, and truth. “Lived out in his own life” gestures to recusant ties and the everyday negotiations of belief in a regime that made religion a matter of surveillance. The ghost becomes a piece of forbidden inheritance - Catholic memory returning in Protestant daylight - and the play’s uncertainty stops looking philosophical and starts looking historical.
The pressure point is the religious mismatch. A Protestant world is, officially, not supposed to have Catholic ghosts. Post-Reformation England tried to banish purgatory, prayers for the dead, and the entire spiritual economy that made a restless spirit legible. Yet Hamlet begins with a figure who behaves like a purgatorial messenger anyway: demanding remembrance, implying unfinished moral accounting, pulling the living into obligations the new theology says shouldn’t exist. That contradiction is the engine. It produces dread not because a ghost appears, but because the ghost’s very category is politically and doctrinally contested.
Greenblatt’s subtext is that Shakespeare stages the national argument inside a family drama: the son trapped between competing scripts for duty, mourning, and truth. “Lived out in his own life” gestures to recusant ties and the everyday negotiations of belief in a regime that made religion a matter of surveillance. The ghost becomes a piece of forbidden inheritance - Catholic memory returning in Protestant daylight - and the play’s uncertainty stops looking philosophical and starts looking historical.
Quote Details
| Topic | Writing |
|---|
More Quotes by Stephen
Add to List
