"Now if there is one thing that we do worse than any other nation, it is try and manage somebody else's affairs"
About this Quote
Rogers lands the punch with a comedian’s deadpan patriotism: America isn’t condemned for being weak, but for being uniquely enthusiastic about meddling. The phrase “one thing” sets up a faux contest of national excellence, then yanks the rug out by naming an “achievement” no country should want. It’s a sly reversal of boosterism, using the language of pride to indict a habit.
“Try and manage” is doing a lot of work. It’s not just “interfere”; it’s the managerial impulse, the confidence that other people’s lives are simply misfiled paperwork awaiting an American fix. The subtext is that this urge is both arrogant and incompetent: we do it “worse,” meaning we bungle the job even by the standards of interventionists. Rogers isn’t offering isolationism as purity; he’s mocking the self-importance that assumes competence where there’s no accountability.
The line also reflects Rogers’ era, when the U.S. was flexing its muscle through interventions in Latin America and the Caribbean, and debating what its growing power was for. Coming out of the interwar period and into the Depression, the quote reads like a warning against confusing strength with wisdom. As an actor and public humorist, Rogers can say what diplomats can’t: that “help” is often a costume for control, and that the more righteous the mission sounds, the less likely it is to end well for the people being “managed.”
“Try and manage” is doing a lot of work. It’s not just “interfere”; it’s the managerial impulse, the confidence that other people’s lives are simply misfiled paperwork awaiting an American fix. The subtext is that this urge is both arrogant and incompetent: we do it “worse,” meaning we bungle the job even by the standards of interventionists. Rogers isn’t offering isolationism as purity; he’s mocking the self-importance that assumes competence where there’s no accountability.
The line also reflects Rogers’ era, when the U.S. was flexing its muscle through interventions in Latin America and the Caribbean, and debating what its growing power was for. Coming out of the interwar period and into the Depression, the quote reads like a warning against confusing strength with wisdom. As an actor and public humorist, Rogers can say what diplomats can’t: that “help” is often a costume for control, and that the more righteous the mission sounds, the less likely it is to end well for the people being “managed.”
Quote Details
| Topic | Peace |
|---|
More Quotes by Will
Add to List
