"Now, in reality, the world have paid too great a compliment to critics, and have imagined them to be men of much greater profundity then they really are"
About this Quote
Fielding’s jab lands because it punctures an old cultural fantasy: that the critic is a kind of secular priest, consecrating taste with mysterious insight. He refuses the mystique. “Paid too great a compliment” frames criticism not as earned authority but as an inflated social salary - reputation as overcompensation. The sly move is that he blames “the world,” not the critics themselves, for the elevation. That’s not generosity; it’s strategy. Fielding is really diagnosing a public hunger to outsource judgment, to treat interpretation as a specialist’s job so ordinary readers don’t have to risk having opinions.
The line also carries the professional irritation of an 18th-century novelist writing in a rapidly commercializing literary marketplace. Periodicals, pamphlets, and coffeehouse commentary were turning criticism into a visible genre, sometimes parasitic, sometimes essential. Fielding, who trafficked in satire and moral comedy, saw how quickly gatekeeping can masquerade as depth. By calling critics less “profound” than imagined, he’s not arguing that art is simple; he’s arguing that critics often perform complexity as a social credential.
There’s a subtler self-defense, too. Novelists in Fielding’s moment were still fighting for respectability against charges of frivolity. If critics are overvalued, then their scorn is overvalued, and the novelist’s supposed inferiority starts to look like a con. The sentence is a pressure release valve: it invites readers to trust their own sensibilities, and it demotes critique from oracle to opinion - sharp, useful, but rarely sacred.
The line also carries the professional irritation of an 18th-century novelist writing in a rapidly commercializing literary marketplace. Periodicals, pamphlets, and coffeehouse commentary were turning criticism into a visible genre, sometimes parasitic, sometimes essential. Fielding, who trafficked in satire and moral comedy, saw how quickly gatekeeping can masquerade as depth. By calling critics less “profound” than imagined, he’s not arguing that art is simple; he’s arguing that critics often perform complexity as a social credential.
There’s a subtler self-defense, too. Novelists in Fielding’s moment were still fighting for respectability against charges of frivolity. If critics are overvalued, then their scorn is overvalued, and the novelist’s supposed inferiority starts to look like a con. The sentence is a pressure release valve: it invites readers to trust their own sensibilities, and it demotes critique from oracle to opinion - sharp, useful, but rarely sacred.
Quote Details
| Topic | Sarcastic |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Henry
Add to List






