"Now, the downside to conservation is that so much is done for the public, which almost always mars the environment that one wanted to conserve"
About this Quote
Conservation, Jacobsen needles, can become its own quiet act of vandalism. The line lands with an architect's eye for unintended consequences: the moment you declare a place worth saving, you also invite the machinery of access, interpretation, and prestige. Trails, signage, parking lots, visitor centers, railings, lighting, even the well-meaning “restoration” palette of materials all arrive wearing the costume of care. The public is framed as both beneficiary and contaminant, not because people are inherently destructive, but because mass appreciation requires infrastructure, and infrastructure is an ecological argument made in concrete.
The subtext is a critique of modernity's compulsion to manage nature into legibility. A conserved environment is rarely allowed to remain indifferent or difficult; it must be made safe, viewable, and narratable. That translation into a public good risks converting an ecosystem into a curated experience, a kind of outdoor museum where the “natural” is maintained like an exhibit. Jacobsen's phrasing is especially sharp: “almost always mars” doesn't leave room for the comforting exception. It suggests a pattern, a structural flaw in the very idea of conservation-as-public-service.
Context matters: Jacobsen worked in a Scandinavian welfare-state era that prized democratic access and rational planning, while also professionalizing landscape and environmental design. His skepticism reads as an insider's warning. The quote isn't anti-conservation so much as anti-triumphalist, insisting that preservation is never neutral. It changes what it touches, even when it claims not to.
The subtext is a critique of modernity's compulsion to manage nature into legibility. A conserved environment is rarely allowed to remain indifferent or difficult; it must be made safe, viewable, and narratable. That translation into a public good risks converting an ecosystem into a curated experience, a kind of outdoor museum where the “natural” is maintained like an exhibit. Jacobsen's phrasing is especially sharp: “almost always mars” doesn't leave room for the comforting exception. It suggests a pattern, a structural flaw in the very idea of conservation-as-public-service.
Context matters: Jacobsen worked in a Scandinavian welfare-state era that prized democratic access and rational planning, while also professionalizing landscape and environmental design. His skepticism reads as an insider's warning. The quote isn't anti-conservation so much as anti-triumphalist, insisting that preservation is never neutral. It changes what it touches, even when it claims not to.
Quote Details
| Topic | Nature |
|---|
More Quotes by Arne
Add to List
