"Now to consult the rules of composition before making a picture is a little like consulting the law of gravitation before going for a walk. Such rules and laws are deduced from the accomplished fact; they are the products of reflection"
About this Quote
Weston drags “rules of composition” off their pedestal by pairing them with gravity: essential, real, but not something you “consult” unless you’re already overthinking the act of moving. The jab is aimed at the timid photographer who treats aesthetics like a checklist, mistaking obedience for vision. By choosing an everyday action - walking - he makes the point feel bodily. Making pictures isn’t primarily an intellectual exercise; it’s a practiced responsiveness to the world.
The subtext is a defense of intuition that isn’t anti-intellectual so much as anti-premature theory. Weston isn’t claiming rules are useless; he’s demoting them to what they actually are: after-the-fact descriptions of what has worked before. “Deduced from the accomplished fact” is the key phrase. Composition “laws” don’t cause great photographs; great photographs cause composition laws. The order matters. He’s arguing for experience first, analysis second - a creative process where the eye learns by doing, and only later names what it learned.
Contextually, this sits neatly in early-to-mid 20th century modernist photography, when Weston and the f/64 crowd were pushing “straight” photography: sharp detail, formal clarity, an insistence that the medium didn’t need to mimic painting’s soft romanticism. In that climate, talk of “rules” often meant inherited art-school formulas. Weston’s line is a manifesto in miniature: stop photographing what you think a good photo should look like, and start photographing until you’ve made something good enough that the rules have to chase you.
The subtext is a defense of intuition that isn’t anti-intellectual so much as anti-premature theory. Weston isn’t claiming rules are useless; he’s demoting them to what they actually are: after-the-fact descriptions of what has worked before. “Deduced from the accomplished fact” is the key phrase. Composition “laws” don’t cause great photographs; great photographs cause composition laws. The order matters. He’s arguing for experience first, analysis second - a creative process where the eye learns by doing, and only later names what it learned.
Contextually, this sits neatly in early-to-mid 20th century modernist photography, when Weston and the f/64 crowd were pushing “straight” photography: sharp detail, formal clarity, an insistence that the medium didn’t need to mimic painting’s soft romanticism. In that climate, talk of “rules” often meant inherited art-school formulas. Weston’s line is a manifesto in miniature: stop photographing what you think a good photo should look like, and start photographing until you’ve made something good enough that the rules have to chase you.
Quote Details
| Topic | Art |
|---|
More Quotes by Edward
Add to List
