"Nowhere in this country should we have laws that permit drinking and driving or drinking in vehicles that are on American highways. This is not rocket science. We know how to prevent this, and 36 states do"
About this Quote
Dorgan is doing something politicians rarely do well: making a policy argument sound like common sense without sounding bloodless. “Nowhere in this country” sets a maximalist frame on purpose. He’s not debating a fine point of transportation law; he’s invoking a national moral baseline. If you allow drinking in a moving vehicle, you’re not merely permissive, you’re negligent.
“This is not rocket science” is the rhetorical cudgel. It preemptively shames would-be skeptics by casting disagreement as either bad faith or stupidity. The line also taps a very American impatience with “overcomplication,” a populist move that says: experts aren’t required here, just backbone. That’s the subtext: the barrier isn’t knowledge, it’s politics.
Then comes the clincher: “We know how to prevent this, and 36 states do.” This is legislative peer pressure dressed as evidence. He’s presenting a ready-made roadmap and implying the remaining states are outliers choosing danger. It’s also a soft federalism argument: if a majority of states have already acted, the policy has been tested in the real world, which blunts claims about unintended consequences or cultural mismatch.
Context matters. Dorgan, a longtime senator, often positioned himself as a plainspoken advocate of pragmatic regulation. This quote fits an era when drunk driving shifted from unfortunate accident to preventable public health crisis, with advocacy groups and state-by-state reforms pushing norms. The intent isn’t just passing a law; it’s recoding the issue as settled, overdue, and frankly embarrassing to resist.
“This is not rocket science” is the rhetorical cudgel. It preemptively shames would-be skeptics by casting disagreement as either bad faith or stupidity. The line also taps a very American impatience with “overcomplication,” a populist move that says: experts aren’t required here, just backbone. That’s the subtext: the barrier isn’t knowledge, it’s politics.
Then comes the clincher: “We know how to prevent this, and 36 states do.” This is legislative peer pressure dressed as evidence. He’s presenting a ready-made roadmap and implying the remaining states are outliers choosing danger. It’s also a soft federalism argument: if a majority of states have already acted, the policy has been tested in the real world, which blunts claims about unintended consequences or cultural mismatch.
Context matters. Dorgan, a longtime senator, often positioned himself as a plainspoken advocate of pragmatic regulation. This quote fits an era when drunk driving shifted from unfortunate accident to preventable public health crisis, with advocacy groups and state-by-state reforms pushing norms. The intent isn’t just passing a law; it’s recoding the issue as settled, overdue, and frankly embarrassing to resist.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Byron
Add to List






