"Of all vices, drinking is the most incompatible with greatness"
About this Quote
Scott’s line has the clipped authority of someone who watched “greatness” get mythologized in real time and didn’t buy the romance. “Of all vices” is an almost legalistic sweep, a rhetorical move that pretends to weigh every sin on the scale and then lands, pointedly, on the one that was socially lubricated and culturally excused. Drinking isn’t framed as merely immoral; it’s framed as structurally incompatible with the kind of sustained discipline greatness requires. That word, incompatible, does the heavy lifting: it suggests not a lapse but a mismatch in design, as if alcohol and achievement can’t occupy the same system without one corroding the other.
The subtext is also a rebuke to the era’s indulgent masculinity. In Scott’s Britain, convivial drinking was a badge of fellowship, status, even patriotism; to call it the vice least suited to greatness is to puncture a cherished national ritual. He’s not preaching temperance in a revivalist register so much as policing the boundary between public legend and private decay. Greatness, for Scott, is less about flashes of genius than about durability: memory, reputation, output. Alcohol threatens all three by making the self unreliable - and unreliability is fatal when your life is being converted into a narrative other people will quote.
There’s an implied self-indictment, too. Scott’s world was crowded with gifted men who drank as if it were part of the job, and he knew how quickly conviviality turns into dependency. The sentence reads like advice delivered after the fact: not moral panic, but the cold clarity of someone tallying costs.
The subtext is also a rebuke to the era’s indulgent masculinity. In Scott’s Britain, convivial drinking was a badge of fellowship, status, even patriotism; to call it the vice least suited to greatness is to puncture a cherished national ritual. He’s not preaching temperance in a revivalist register so much as policing the boundary between public legend and private decay. Greatness, for Scott, is less about flashes of genius than about durability: memory, reputation, output. Alcohol threatens all three by making the self unreliable - and unreliability is fatal when your life is being converted into a narrative other people will quote.
There’s an implied self-indictment, too. Scott’s world was crowded with gifted men who drank as if it were part of the job, and he knew how quickly conviviality turns into dependency. The sentence reads like advice delivered after the fact: not moral panic, but the cold clarity of someone tallying costs.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Walter
Add to List









