"Of puns it has been said that those who most dislike them are those who are least able to utter them"
About this Quote
Poe’s jab lands with the elegance of a trap: he pretends to defend puns while quietly prosecuting the people who sneer at them. The line is built like a parlor-room syllogism, the kind of “it has been said” hearsay that lets him sound above the fray even as he sharpens the knife. Dislike puns? That’s not taste, he implies; it’s incompetence dressed up as discernment. The insult is social, not merely aesthetic: the anti-pun purist isn’t refined, just outmatched.
The subtext is class anxiety in miniature. Wordplay is a performance of agility, a public proof that you can pivot meanings on command. Poe reframes pun-hatred as sour grapes, the reflex of someone who can’t keep up with the room’s fastest mind. In a culture where “serious” literature was busy separating itself from cheap laughter and popular entertainment, the pun became a convenient dividing line. Poe pokes that line until it squeals.
Context matters: Poe was both a high-art craftsman and a magazine-era working writer, living off an audience that loved cleverness and bite. He knew that wit could be a weapon and a paycheck. So the quip doubles as self-positioning: he aligns himself with verbal virtuosity and casts his critics as humorless amateurs. It’s not just a defense of puns; it’s a defense of literary dexterity, and a reminder that contempt is often a mask for embarrassment.
The subtext is class anxiety in miniature. Wordplay is a performance of agility, a public proof that you can pivot meanings on command. Poe reframes pun-hatred as sour grapes, the reflex of someone who can’t keep up with the room’s fastest mind. In a culture where “serious” literature was busy separating itself from cheap laughter and popular entertainment, the pun became a convenient dividing line. Poe pokes that line until it squeals.
Context matters: Poe was both a high-art craftsman and a magazine-era working writer, living off an audience that loved cleverness and bite. He knew that wit could be a weapon and a paycheck. So the quip doubles as self-positioning: he aligns himself with verbal virtuosity and casts his critics as humorless amateurs. It’s not just a defense of puns; it’s a defense of literary dexterity, and a reminder that contempt is often a mask for embarrassment.
Quote Details
| Topic | Puns & Wordplay |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Edgar
Add to List







