Daily Inspiration Quote by Edward Thorndike

"On the whole, the psychological work of the last quarter of the nineteenth century emphasized the study of consciousness to the neglect of the total life of intellect and character"

Edward Thorndike, Psychologist

About this Quote

Thorndike is taking aim at psychology when it still fancied itself a kind of refined introspection club. In the late 1800s, the prestige method was to peer inward, catalog “conscious” experience, and treat that inventory as the royal road to mind. His sentence looks mild, but the jab is surgical: “on the whole” signals a measured historian’s voice, while “to the neglect” is an accusation. The real target isn’t consciousness itself; it’s the profession’s lopsided definition of what counts as evidence.

The subtext is Thorndike’s own agenda arriving in the form of a critique. As an architect of educational psychology and a champion of measurement, he’s clearing the runway for a broader, more practical science: one that can describe learning, habit, performance, and behavior without relying on self-report or philosophical vocabulary. “Total life of intellect and character” is doing double duty. It invokes moral and social stakes (character as conduct, not merely thought) while insisting that cognition is inseparable from the patterns that show up in classrooms, workplaces, and institutions.

Context matters: this is the moment when psychology is renegotiating its identity, moving from Wundt-style introspection toward functionalism and, soon, behaviorism. Thorndike’s line compresses that pivot into a single contrast: consciousness as an elite, private theater versus intellect and character as observable, consequential, and educable. It works because it frames a methodological dispute as a moral one: a science that ignores “total life” risks becoming accurate about the least important slice of human experience.

Quote Details

Topic	Knowledge
Source	Help us find the source
Cite	Cite this Quote

More Quotes by Edward Add to List

About the Author

Edward Thorndike

Edward Thorndike (August 31, 1874 - August 9, 1949) was a Psychologist from USA.

24 more quotes available

View Profile

Similar Quotes

"The major task of the twentieth century will be to explore the unconscious, to investigate the subsoil of the mind"

Henri Bergson, Philosopher

"The development of the meaning attaching to the personal self, the conscious being, is the subject matter of the history of psychology"

James M. Baldwin, Psychologist

"Within psychology and neuroscience, some new and rigorous experimental paradigms for studying consciousness have helped it begin to overcome the stigma that has been attached to the topic for most of this century"

David Chalmers, Philosopher

"The nineteenth century was completely lacking in logic, it had cosmic terms and hopes, and aspirations, and discoveries, and ideals but it had no logic"

Gertrude Stein, Author

Gertrude Stein

"I was brought up in the great tradition of the late nineteenth century: that a writer never complains, never explains and never disdains"

James A. Michener, Novelist

"The restriction of studies of human intellect and character to studies of conscious states was not without influence on a scientific studies of animal psychology"

Edward Thorndike, Psychologist

Edward Thorndike

"In pure literature, the writers of the eighteenth century achieved, indeed, many triumphs; but their great, their peculiar, triumphs were in the domain of thought"

Lytton Strachey, Critic

"The nineteenth century believed in science but the twentieth century does not"

Gertrude Stein, Author

Gertrude Stein

"A study of the history of opinion is a necessary preliminary to the emancipation of the mind"

John Maynard Keynes, Economist

"In my opinion, the most significant works of the twentieth century are those that rise beyond the conceptual tyranny of genre; they are, at the same time, poetry, criticism, narrative, drama, etc"

Juan Goytisolo, Poet

"But the eighteenth century, on the whole, loathed melancholy"

George Saintsbury, Writer

"Doubt, it seems to me, is the central condition of a human being in the twentieth century"

Salman Rushdie, Novelist

"If any imagine from the literary tone of the preceding remarks that we are indifferent to the radical movement for the benefit of the masses which is the crowning glory of the nineteenth century, they will soon discover their egregious mistake"

George Ripley, Activist

"The monotony and solitude of a quiet life stimulates the creative mind"

Albert Einstein, Physicist

Albert Einstein

"In the 19th century, you had bourgeois art without politics - an almost frozen idea of what beauty is"

Douglas Sirk, Director

"There are people who possess not so much genius as a certain talent for perceiving the desires of the century, or even of the decade, before it has done so itself"

Georg C. Lichtenberg, Scientist

Georg C. Lichtenberg

"The lived experiences which could not find adequate scientific expression in the substance doctrine of rational psychology were now validated in light of new and better methods"

Wilhelm Dilthey, Historian

Wilhelm Dilthey

"Some years ago, I wrote a book called the Emperor's New Mind and that book was describing a point of view I had about consciousness and why it was not something that comes about from complicated calculations"

Roger Penrose, Physicist

"A technical survey that systematize, digest, and appraise the mid century state of psychology"

Stanley Smith Stevens, Psychologist

Stanley Smith Stevens

"I've always been a fan of the 19th century novel, of the novel that is plotted, character-driven, and where the passage of time is almost as central to the novel as a major minor character, the passage of time and its effect on the characters in the story"

John Irving, Novelist