"On this National Agriculture Day, when we all should be taking time to thank and pay tribute to America's farmers, ranchers and their families who produce the food for our tables, we are finding those same people in dire need of our help and support"
About this Quote
A holiday proclamation that turns into a quiet alarm bell. McCaul opens with the ritual language of civic gratitude - "thank and pay tribute" - the kind of bipartisan sentiment that costs nothing and signals wholesomeness. Then he pivots hard: the people we celebrate are "in dire need of our help and support". The intent is to convert a feel-good calendar moment into political leverage, reframing National Agriculture Day from a symbolic pat on the back into a mandate for action.
The subtext is a familiar American bargain: farmers feed the nation; the nation owes farmers stability. By invoking "the food for our tables", he personalizes agriculture as domestic security, not just an industry. It's a strategic compression of distance: the rural producer and the suburban consumer are tied together by dinner, not ideology. That move also pre-empts skepticism about subsidies or intervention. If your meal depends on their survival, assistance becomes reciprocity rather than favoritism.
Context matters: McCaul, a Texas Republican known more for national security than farm policy, is borrowing the language of vulnerability usually reserved for soldiers, disaster victims, or essential workers. "Those same people" carries a faint accusation - that public praise has become a substitute for material support, that we like the myth of the self-reliant farmer more than we like confronting the economics that make farming precarious.
It works because it weaponizes irony without sounding cynical: the day designed to honor farmers is presented as evidence of how little honor actually pays.
The subtext is a familiar American bargain: farmers feed the nation; the nation owes farmers stability. By invoking "the food for our tables", he personalizes agriculture as domestic security, not just an industry. It's a strategic compression of distance: the rural producer and the suburban consumer are tied together by dinner, not ideology. That move also pre-empts skepticism about subsidies or intervention. If your meal depends on their survival, assistance becomes reciprocity rather than favoritism.
Context matters: McCaul, a Texas Republican known more for national security than farm policy, is borrowing the language of vulnerability usually reserved for soldiers, disaster victims, or essential workers. "Those same people" carries a faint accusation - that public praise has become a substitute for material support, that we like the myth of the self-reliant farmer more than we like confronting the economics that make farming precarious.
It works because it weaponizes irony without sounding cynical: the day designed to honor farmers is presented as evidence of how little honor actually pays.
Quote Details
| Topic | Thank You |
|---|
More Quotes by Michael
Add to List
