"Once the state has been founded, there can no longer be any heroes. They come on the scene only in uncivilized conditions"
About this Quote
Hegel’s line lands like an insult disguised as a sociology lesson: if you’re still getting “heroes,” your political life hasn’t grown up. The jab is deliberate. For Hegel, history isn’t a scrapbook of great men; it’s a process that moves from raw, personalized power toward rational institutions. Heroes, in this framing, are not moral exemplars but emergency improvisers - the kind of figures who can force coherence onto chaos because there is no stable machinery to do it yet.
The specific intent is to demote heroism from an eternal virtue to a transitional job description. A hero appears when a society lacks a state robust enough to mediate conflicts, administer justice, and make collective life legible. Once the state is “founded,” the drama is supposed to drain out of politics. Law replaces charisma; offices replace saviors; procedure replaces spectacle. That’s the promise and the threat: the mature state doesn’t need exceptional individuals because it has normalized the functions that heroes once performed.
The subtext is sharper. Hero-worship is a symptom of underdevelopment, a sign that people are still relating to power as a person, not a system. Hegel is also quietly warning that the craving for heroes can be politically regressive: it invites the return of arbitrary will precisely where the modern state claims to have installed reason.
Context matters: Hegel is writing in the shadow of the French Revolution and Napoleon, whom he famously viewed as a “world-historical” figure. He’s not denying that history produces titans; he’s arguing they erupt when the social order is unfinished - and that a truly “civilized” political order should make them unnecessary, even impossible.
The specific intent is to demote heroism from an eternal virtue to a transitional job description. A hero appears when a society lacks a state robust enough to mediate conflicts, administer justice, and make collective life legible. Once the state is “founded,” the drama is supposed to drain out of politics. Law replaces charisma; offices replace saviors; procedure replaces spectacle. That’s the promise and the threat: the mature state doesn’t need exceptional individuals because it has normalized the functions that heroes once performed.
The subtext is sharper. Hero-worship is a symptom of underdevelopment, a sign that people are still relating to power as a person, not a system. Hegel is also quietly warning that the craving for heroes can be politically regressive: it invites the return of arbitrary will precisely where the modern state claims to have installed reason.
Context matters: Hegel is writing in the shadow of the French Revolution and Napoleon, whom he famously viewed as a “world-historical” figure. He’s not denying that history produces titans; he’s arguing they erupt when the social order is unfinished - and that a truly “civilized” political order should make them unnecessary, even impossible.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|
More Quotes by Georg
Add to List
