"One cannot govern with 'buts'"
About this Quote
De Gaulle’s line has the clipped impatience of a man who watched a state collapse in real time. “One cannot govern with ‘buts’” isn’t anti-nuance; it’s anti-paralysis. The word “buts” stands in for the entire ecology of French political life he distrusted: coalition horsetrading, procedural hedging, moralizing caveats that sound prudent while evacuating responsibility. It’s a jab at the habit of treating power as a seminar, where every commitment arrives with a footnote and every decision is postponed until the objections feel adequately honored.
The genius is in the grammar. “One cannot” makes it sound like a law of physics, not a preference. Governance, in this telling, isn’t the art of balancing competing goods; it’s the act of choosing amid conflict and then carrying the choice. De Gaulle’s subtext is that legitimacy comes from clarity and follow-through, not from constantly announcing your inner complexity. A leader who governs by “but” is always auditioning for absolution: yes, I did this, but consider my constraints, my rivals, my principles, the weather.
The context matters: Free France, postwar reconstruction, the Algerian crisis, and the founding of the Fifth Republic. De Gaulle built institutions around the premise embedded here: a strong executive to cut through veto points and rhetorical dithering. It’s a warning and a provocation. Democracies need argument; they also need moments when argument stops and accountability begins.
The genius is in the grammar. “One cannot” makes it sound like a law of physics, not a preference. Governance, in this telling, isn’t the art of balancing competing goods; it’s the act of choosing amid conflict and then carrying the choice. De Gaulle’s subtext is that legitimacy comes from clarity and follow-through, not from constantly announcing your inner complexity. A leader who governs by “but” is always auditioning for absolution: yes, I did this, but consider my constraints, my rivals, my principles, the weather.
The context matters: Free France, postwar reconstruction, the Algerian crisis, and the founding of the Fifth Republic. De Gaulle built institutions around the premise embedded here: a strong executive to cut through veto points and rhetorical dithering. It’s a warning and a provocation. Democracies need argument; they also need moments when argument stops and accountability begins.
Quote Details
| Topic | Decision-Making |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Gaulle, Charles de. (2026, January 15). One cannot govern with 'buts'. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/one-cannot-govern-with-buts-49652/
Chicago Style
Gaulle, Charles de. "One cannot govern with 'buts'." FixQuotes. January 15, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/one-cannot-govern-with-buts-49652/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"One cannot govern with 'buts'." FixQuotes, 15 Jan. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/one-cannot-govern-with-buts-49652/. Accessed 12 Feb. 2026.
More Quotes by Charles
Add to List













