"One forgets too easily the difference between a man and his image, and that there is none between the sound of his voice on the screen and in real life"
About this Quote
Brecht is needling a modern weakness: the way mediated presence pretends to be presence, then quietly replaces it. His line turns on a double move. First, he warns that we confuse a man with his image - not because we are stupid, but because images are engineered to feel complete. Second, he sharpens the trap: sound, especially, bullies us into intimacy. A filmed face can read as performance; a recorded voice lands as evidence. We trust what we hear as if it were unfiltered, as if timbre equals truth.
That is classic Brecht: expose the stage machinery so the audience stops surrendering. In his theater, the point of alienation is not coldness for its own sake; it is ethical distance. If viewers forget the difference between person and representation, they also forget the difference between politics and spectacle. The quote sits in the cultural moment when radio, film, and amplified speech were reorganizing public life - and when fascist aesthetics proved that mass media could manufacture sincerity at scale.
The subtext is almost accusatory: you are being made comfortable. A screen voice feels like proximity, but it is a one-way channel; it can’t be questioned, it can’t be interrupted, it can’t be held accountable in the messy reciprocity of real life. Brecht is describing how technology launders authority. Once the image becomes the person, criticism starts to feel like heresy, and the audience becomes a congregation.
That is classic Brecht: expose the stage machinery so the audience stops surrendering. In his theater, the point of alienation is not coldness for its own sake; it is ethical distance. If viewers forget the difference between person and representation, they also forget the difference between politics and spectacle. The quote sits in the cultural moment when radio, film, and amplified speech were reorganizing public life - and when fascist aesthetics proved that mass media could manufacture sincerity at scale.
The subtext is almost accusatory: you are being made comfortable. A screen voice feels like proximity, but it is a one-way channel; it can’t be questioned, it can’t be interrupted, it can’t be held accountable in the messy reciprocity of real life. Brecht is describing how technology launders authority. Once the image becomes the person, criticism starts to feel like heresy, and the audience becomes a congregation.
Quote Details
| Topic | Movie |
|---|
More Quotes by Bertolt
Add to List
