"One layer was certainly 17th century. The 18th century in him is obvious. There was the 19th century, and a large slice, of course, of the 20th century; and another, curious layer which may possibly have been the 21st"
About this Quote
Attlee’s genius here is that he flatters and files down at the same time: a portrait of a man as a geological cross-section, thick with eras, suggesting depth while quietly implying misfit. Calling someone “certainly 17th century” isn’t a compliment so much as a diagnosis - a hint of austerity, dogma, or old pieties that refuse to die. The “obvious” 18th century layer adds rational polish and elite self-confidence; the 19th century brings empire’s moral certainty and industrial-scale seriousness. By the time Attlee reaches “a large slice…of the 20th century,” he’s conceding modernity, but only as one ingredient in a crowded mix.
The subtext is political judgment disguised as literary taxonomy. This is a leader speaking in the measured tones of a man who spent his career translating personality into governance. Attlee, the Labour prime minister who built the postwar welfare state, is weighing a rival or colleague by historical temperament: not merely what he believes, but which century he’s emotionally loyal to. That matters in a Britain remaking itself after World War II, when nostalgia could be either ballast or sabotage.
Then comes the deft sting: “another, curious layer…possibly…21st.” The hedge (“may possibly”) signals skepticism about supposed futurism, as if the subject’s modern ideas feel accidental, decorative, or not fully earned. Attlee’s rhetoric works because it turns time into character: progress isn’t a straight line, it’s a stack of inherited reflexes. In that stack, you can hear the question that haunted postwar leadership: is this person equipped for what’s coming, or merely well-stocked with yesterday?
The subtext is political judgment disguised as literary taxonomy. This is a leader speaking in the measured tones of a man who spent his career translating personality into governance. Attlee, the Labour prime minister who built the postwar welfare state, is weighing a rival or colleague by historical temperament: not merely what he believes, but which century he’s emotionally loyal to. That matters in a Britain remaking itself after World War II, when nostalgia could be either ballast or sabotage.
Then comes the deft sting: “another, curious layer…possibly…21st.” The hedge (“may possibly”) signals skepticism about supposed futurism, as if the subject’s modern ideas feel accidental, decorative, or not fully earned. Attlee’s rhetoric works because it turns time into character: progress isn’t a straight line, it’s a stack of inherited reflexes. In that stack, you can hear the question that haunted postwar leadership: is this person equipped for what’s coming, or merely well-stocked with yesterday?
Quote Details
| Topic | Time |
|---|
More Quotes by Clement
Add to List






