"One man cannot practice many arts with success"
About this Quote
Plato is laying down a rule that sounds like career advice but functions as political architecture. “One man cannot practice many arts with success” is less a shrug at human limitation than a blueprint for an ordered city: specialization as moral discipline. In The Republic, this idea sits inside his larger argument that justice is not a feeling or a slogan but a structure - a society becomes “just” when each person does the work they are naturally suited to and doesn’t trespass into other roles. The line’s calm certainty is part of its force. No qualifiers, no room for the Renaissance ideal. It reads like common sense, which is exactly how Plato wants ideology to travel.
The subtext is anxiety about the messy, improvisational reality of Athens: citizens who are also jurors, soldiers, demagogues, merchants; poets who shape public emotion; sophists who teach persuasion untethered from truth. Plato’s suspicion of that fluidity runs deep. Multiple “arts” don’t just dilute excellence; they blur identity, invite faction, and empower clever people who can perform competence across domains without possessing wisdom in any.
It’s also a quiet attack on the prestige economy. If your society rewards versatility, it rewards performance. Plato prefers the slow legitimacy of mastery, ideally supervised by philosopher-kings who, in a delicious contradiction, are expected to master the highest “art” of all: ruling. The quote works because it flatters discipline while smuggling in control - a neat philosophical move that turns personal limitation into civic destiny.
The subtext is anxiety about the messy, improvisational reality of Athens: citizens who are also jurors, soldiers, demagogues, merchants; poets who shape public emotion; sophists who teach persuasion untethered from truth. Plato’s suspicion of that fluidity runs deep. Multiple “arts” don’t just dilute excellence; they blur identity, invite faction, and empower clever people who can perform competence across domains without possessing wisdom in any.
It’s also a quiet attack on the prestige economy. If your society rewards versatility, it rewards performance. Plato prefers the slow legitimacy of mastery, ideally supervised by philosopher-kings who, in a delicious contradiction, are expected to master the highest “art” of all: ruling. The quote works because it flatters discipline while smuggling in control - a neat philosophical move that turns personal limitation into civic destiny.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Plato
Add to List





