"One might as well try to ride two horses moving in different directions, as to try to maintain in equal force two opposing or contradictory sets of desires"
About this Quote
The specific intent is corrective, and a little prosecutorial. “One might as well” frames the problem as already decided by common sense. He’s warning the ambitious striver - Collier’s core audience as a publisher of motivational, success-minded material - that mixed motives don’t just slow you down; they pull you apart. The subtext is a critique of genteel indecision: if you keep saying you want both freedom and certainty, both admiration and privacy, both comfort and transformation, you’re not complex. You’re stalled.
Context matters: early 20th-century American uplift culture treated desire as an engine to be tuned, not a mystery to be honored. Collier’s metaphor belongs to that era’s practical psychology, when “conflicting desires” were the saboteur inside every productivity plan. What makes the quote durable is that it also anticipates a modern truth: we’re constantly asked to perform incompatible identities - hustle and self-care, authenticity and branding. Collier’s point lands like a blunt editorial note: pick a direction, or the split will pick you.
Quote Details
| Topic | Decision-Making |
|---|---|
| Source | Verified source: The Secret of the Ages (Robert Collier, 1926)
Evidence: One might as well try to ride two horses moving in different directions, as to try to maintain in equal force two opposing or contradictory sets of desires. (Page 104 (per later reprints/editions; exact page varies by edition)). Primary source attribution: the quote is attributed to Robert Collier in his own work, The Secret of the Ages, which Open Library lists with publish date 1926 and publisher R. Collier. Many modern quote sites cite a much later reprint (e.g., a 2013 Lulu edition) and give a page number (commonly p. 104), but that page reference is edition-dependent and not reliable for pinpointing the FIRST 1926 printing without consulting a scan of the 1926 edition. Sacred-texts hosts an HTML transcription labeled [1926] for The Secret of the Ages, but its built-in page index appears to be behind an access restriction at times, so I could not verify the exact original 1926 page in that online transcription during this lookup. Other candidates (1) The Secret of the Ages: And Other Essential Works (Robert Collier, 2022) compilation98.2% (Library of Spiritual Wisdom) Robert Collier. The Struggle for Existence ... One might as well try to ride two horses... |
| Cite |
Citation Formats
APA Style (7th ed.)
Collier, Robert. (2026, March 1). One might as well try to ride two horses moving in different directions, as to try to maintain in equal force two opposing or contradictory sets of desires. FixQuotes. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/one-might-as-well-try-to-ride-two-horses-moving-8884/
Chicago Style
Collier, Robert. "One might as well try to ride two horses moving in different directions, as to try to maintain in equal force two opposing or contradictory sets of desires." FixQuotes. March 1, 2026. https://fixquotes.com/quotes/one-might-as-well-try-to-ride-two-horses-moving-8884/.
MLA Style (9th ed.)
"One might as well try to ride two horses moving in different directions, as to try to maintain in equal force two opposing or contradictory sets of desires." FixQuotes, 1 Mar. 2026, https://fixquotes.com/quotes/one-might-as-well-try-to-ride-two-horses-moving-8884/. Accessed 5 Mar. 2026.











