"One of the lessons of history is that nothing is often a good thing to do and always a clever thing to say"
About this Quote
Durant’s line flatters our self-image as decisive actors while quietly indicting it. As a historian, he’s spent a career watching people with power confuse motion with progress; the sentence is a prophylactic against that reflex. “Nothing” is doing double duty: it’s not nihilism, it’s restraint. The claim is less about laziness than about timing - the underrated skill of not escalating, not legislating, not “making a mark” just to prove you’re alive.
The subtext is that history’s disasters are often authored by the overconfident: leaders who can’t tolerate ambiguity, governments that need to be seen responding, ideologues who treat every problem like a nail because they brought a hammer. Durant’s phrasing exposes how incentives skew toward action. Action is legible, fundable, campaignable. Inaction can look like weakness, even when it’s wisdom. So he gives “nothing” an advocate’s brief: it’s “often” good, meaning frequently the least-worst option in complex systems where unintended consequences are the rule, not the exception.
Then comes the sly pivot: “always a clever thing to say.” That’s Durant winking at rhetoric’s magic trick. Praising inaction costs nothing and signals sophistication - the worldly pose of the person who sees beyond the mob’s impatience. It’s also a warning about armchair prudence: the line between strategic restraint and self-protective passivity is thin. In context, it’s a historian reminding the present that the most dangerous impulse isn’t malice; it’s the anxious need to do something, anything, right now.
The subtext is that history’s disasters are often authored by the overconfident: leaders who can’t tolerate ambiguity, governments that need to be seen responding, ideologues who treat every problem like a nail because they brought a hammer. Durant’s phrasing exposes how incentives skew toward action. Action is legible, fundable, campaignable. Inaction can look like weakness, even when it’s wisdom. So he gives “nothing” an advocate’s brief: it’s “often” good, meaning frequently the least-worst option in complex systems where unintended consequences are the rule, not the exception.
Then comes the sly pivot: “always a clever thing to say.” That’s Durant winking at rhetoric’s magic trick. Praising inaction costs nothing and signals sophistication - the worldly pose of the person who sees beyond the mob’s impatience. It’s also a warning about armchair prudence: the line between strategic restraint and self-protective passivity is thin. In context, it’s a historian reminding the present that the most dangerous impulse isn’t malice; it’s the anxious need to do something, anything, right now.
Quote Details
| Topic | Witty One-Liners |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Will
Add to List






