"One of the techniques terrorists employ is to allege torture and mistreatment when they are captured, regardless of whether it is true"
About this Quote
“Regardless of whether it is true” is doing almost all the work here: it preemptively downgrades claims of abuse into a propaganda tactic, not a factual allegation demanding scrutiny. Chavez frames “terrorists” as strategic narrators who weaponize victimhood, inviting the reader to treat reports of torture less as evidence to investigate and more as noise to discount. It’s a rhetorical inoculation: once you accept the premise, any future accusation can be filed under “enemy technique,” and the burden subtly shifts from authorities proving humane conduct to prisoners proving they’re not lying.
The specific intent is defensive, aimed at insulating U.S. policy and public confidence during the post-9/11 era, when detention sites, “enhanced interrogation,” and leaked photos and memos made mistreatment a political liability. By calling the allegation itself a “technique,” the quote implies bad faith as default, collapsing a wide range of detainees and circumstances into a single adversarial category. That move matters because torture is uniquely corrosive to democracies: it’s not just an operational question but a legitimacy crisis. The line tries to cordon off that crisis by casting it as an information war problem.
The subtext isn’t merely “they lie.” It’s “you don’t have to listen.” The risk is that it trains audiences to confuse skepticism with moral permission, treating accountability as naivete and evidence-gathering as aiding the enemy. Even if some captives do invent stories, the quote’s structure encourages a blanket dismissal precisely where societies most need careful, verifiable standards.
The specific intent is defensive, aimed at insulating U.S. policy and public confidence during the post-9/11 era, when detention sites, “enhanced interrogation,” and leaked photos and memos made mistreatment a political liability. By calling the allegation itself a “technique,” the quote implies bad faith as default, collapsing a wide range of detainees and circumstances into a single adversarial category. That move matters because torture is uniquely corrosive to democracies: it’s not just an operational question but a legitimacy crisis. The line tries to cordon off that crisis by casting it as an information war problem.
The subtext isn’t merely “they lie.” It’s “you don’t have to listen.” The risk is that it trains audiences to confuse skepticism with moral permission, treating accountability as naivete and evidence-gathering as aiding the enemy. Even if some captives do invent stories, the quote’s structure encourages a blanket dismissal precisely where societies most need careful, verifiable standards.
Quote Details
| Topic | Human Rights |
|---|
More Quotes by Linda
Add to List
