"One thing I learned a long time ago as a prosecutor is that it's tough to get people to obey a law if there is not penalty for breaking it"
About this Quote
Law, Barnes reminds us, is not a sermon; it is leverage. The line carries the clipped pragmatism of someone who’s watched lofty statutes collapse in the fluorescent-lit reality of courtrooms. As a prosecutor, he learned that “obey” is rarely a matter of moral agreement. It’s a cost-benefit calculation made in ordinary moments: Do I speed? Do I cut corners? Do I ignore this rule because everyone else does? Barnes’ phrasing is almost blunt to the point of banality, and that’s the point. He’s stripping away the comforting civic myth that laws work because they’re written down.
The specific intent is political as much as it is procedural. A former governor and career public official doesn’t float this idea in a vacuum; it’s a justification for enforcement regimes - fines, licensing consequences, jail time, regulatory teeth. When policymakers get accused of being “soft” or when an unfunded mandate is exposed as symbolic, this is the counterpunch: without penalties, you’re governing with vibes.
The subtext is a warning about performative legislation. Passing a law lets leaders claim virtue; funding inspectors, empowering prosecutors, and accepting the backlash of punishment is the part that tests seriousness. There’s also an uncomfortable edge: penalties don’t just encourage compliance, they distribute pain. Barnes’ prosecutor’s realism can read as necessary honesty or as a quiet endorsement of a system that relies on coercion because persuasion is harder.
Contextually, it fits an era of governance increasingly built around “accountability” rhetoric - where the debate isn’t whether rules should exist, but whether the state will actually make them felt.
The specific intent is political as much as it is procedural. A former governor and career public official doesn’t float this idea in a vacuum; it’s a justification for enforcement regimes - fines, licensing consequences, jail time, regulatory teeth. When policymakers get accused of being “soft” or when an unfunded mandate is exposed as symbolic, this is the counterpunch: without penalties, you’re governing with vibes.
The subtext is a warning about performative legislation. Passing a law lets leaders claim virtue; funding inspectors, empowering prosecutors, and accepting the backlash of punishment is the part that tests seriousness. There’s also an uncomfortable edge: penalties don’t just encourage compliance, they distribute pain. Barnes’ prosecutor’s realism can read as necessary honesty or as a quiet endorsement of a system that relies on coercion because persuasion is harder.
Contextually, it fits an era of governance increasingly built around “accountability” rhetoric - where the debate isn’t whether rules should exist, but whether the state will actually make them felt.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Roy
Add to List







