"One thing I was thinking about is that they probably get their come-uppance about the same percentage that people in real life do. Basically, stealing for all practical purposes might as well be legal in New York"
About this Quote
Mike Judge’s genius is that he can make a throwaway complaint sound like an anthropological finding. “They probably get their come-uppance about the same percentage that people in real life do” isn’t just cynicism; it’s a deadpan attack on the comforting fiction that the world is self-correcting. In sitcoms and cop shows, theft gets wrapped up neatly: villains are caught, order is restored, morality pays out. Judge shrugs at that narrative and replaces it with a grim actuarial table. Justice, he implies, isn’t a force. It’s a probability distribution, and the odds aren’t great.
The New York line does the heavier lifting. “Basically, stealing... might as well be legal” isn’t a policy claim so much as a satire of lived experience: if enforcement is inconsistent, if the burden of consequences falls randomly or not at all, legality becomes theater. Judge’s wording is key: “for all practical purposes” signals a practical citizen’s view of law, not a lawyer’s. Law is defined by outcomes, not statutes.
Subtextually, it’s also a jab at the way urban life trains people into low-grade resignation. You adapt, you stop expecting restitution, you internalize the idea that some losses are just the cost of being in the system. Judge isn’t romanticizing lawlessness; he’s mocking the gap between civic promise and civic performance, where “come-uppance” becomes another kind of fiction we tell ourselves to sleep at night.
The New York line does the heavier lifting. “Basically, stealing... might as well be legal” isn’t a policy claim so much as a satire of lived experience: if enforcement is inconsistent, if the burden of consequences falls randomly or not at all, legality becomes theater. Judge’s wording is key: “for all practical purposes” signals a practical citizen’s view of law, not a lawyer’s. Law is defined by outcomes, not statutes.
Subtextually, it’s also a jab at the way urban life trains people into low-grade resignation. You adapt, you stop expecting restitution, you internalize the idea that some losses are just the cost of being in the system. Judge isn’t romanticizing lawlessness; he’s mocking the gap between civic promise and civic performance, where “come-uppance” becomes another kind of fiction we tell ourselves to sleep at night.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Mike
Add to List







