"One with the law is a majority"
About this Quote
A whole political philosophy gets smuggled into nine words: legitimacy beats loudness. Coolidge frames “majority” not as a headcount but as a moral and institutional status conferred by “the law.” It’s a line that flatters the solitary dissenter, but only if that dissenter is aligned with the existing legal order. The power move is its reversal of democratic instinct: instead of law being the product of majority will, the majority is redefined as whatever stands with law.
The subtext is conservative and stabilizing, in the small-c sense. Coolidge, the apostle of restraint after the turbulence of war, labor unrest, and rapid modernization, is offering a calming myth: the system is strong enough that it doesn’t need crowds to validate it. It also grants dignity to unpopular decisions by casting them as inherently majoritarian once they’re legal. That’s rhetoric with consequences. It reassures officials facing pressure, judges facing outrage, and citizens tempted to see numbers as the only source of authority.
But the line has a sharp edge: it can sanctify the status quo. “The law” is not synonymous with justice; it’s a tool, written and enforced by people with power. Coolidge’s formulation invites a particular kind of civic quietism: if legality equals majority, then protest starts to look like futility or even illegitimacy by definition.
In the 1920s, with Prohibition, immigration restriction, and crackdowns on radicals in living memory, that ambiguity isn’t academic. The quote is comforting to institutions, bracing to activists, and a reminder that “majority rule” is always competing with something older: rule by rules.
The subtext is conservative and stabilizing, in the small-c sense. Coolidge, the apostle of restraint after the turbulence of war, labor unrest, and rapid modernization, is offering a calming myth: the system is strong enough that it doesn’t need crowds to validate it. It also grants dignity to unpopular decisions by casting them as inherently majoritarian once they’re legal. That’s rhetoric with consequences. It reassures officials facing pressure, judges facing outrage, and citizens tempted to see numbers as the only source of authority.
But the line has a sharp edge: it can sanctify the status quo. “The law” is not synonymous with justice; it’s a tool, written and enforced by people with power. Coolidge’s formulation invites a particular kind of civic quietism: if legality equals majority, then protest starts to look like futility or even illegitimacy by definition.
In the 1920s, with Prohibition, immigration restriction, and crackdowns on radicals in living memory, that ambiguity isn’t academic. The quote is comforting to institutions, bracing to activists, and a reminder that “majority rule” is always competing with something older: rule by rules.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|
More Quotes by Calvin
Add to List
