"Only reason can convince us of those three fundamental truths without a recognition of which there can be no effective liberty: that what we believe is not necessarily true; that what we like is not necessarily good; and that all questions are open"
About this Quote
Bell’s triad lands like a cold splash on the face of anyone who confuses conviction with clarity. As a critic shaped by early 20th-century modernism and the aftershocks of Victorian certainty, he’s defending liberty not as a patriotic slogan but as a mental discipline: the ability to hold your own mind at arm’s length. The line “Only reason can convince us” is doing double duty. It praises rational inquiry while quietly accusing most of us of running on something else entirely - habit, appetite, tribe.
Each “fundamental truth” targets a different kind of self-deception. “What we believe is not necessarily true” punctures dogma: the comfort of a settled worldview. “What we like is not necessarily good” goes after aesthetics and morality alike, a pointed move from an art critic who watched taste become a social weapon and a political alibi. “All questions are open” is the most radical claim, because it denies the sacredness of any final answer. It’s less libertarian than it sounds: openness isn’t permissiveness, it’s accountability. If questions stay open, you don’t get to stop thinking just because you’ve arrived at a pleasing conclusion.
The subtext is a warning about how liberty collapses from the inside. Censorship doesn’t only come from the state; it comes from our own shortcuts - the itch to turn preference into principle, belonging into “truth.” Bell’s intent is to make freedom contingent on skepticism, and to suggest that a society’s real constitution is its epistemology: how it decides what counts as real, good, and debatable.
Each “fundamental truth” targets a different kind of self-deception. “What we believe is not necessarily true” punctures dogma: the comfort of a settled worldview. “What we like is not necessarily good” goes after aesthetics and morality alike, a pointed move from an art critic who watched taste become a social weapon and a political alibi. “All questions are open” is the most radical claim, because it denies the sacredness of any final answer. It’s less libertarian than it sounds: openness isn’t permissiveness, it’s accountability. If questions stay open, you don’t get to stop thinking just because you’ve arrived at a pleasing conclusion.
The subtext is a warning about how liberty collapses from the inside. Censorship doesn’t only come from the state; it comes from our own shortcuts - the itch to turn preference into principle, belonging into “truth.” Bell’s intent is to make freedom contingent on skepticism, and to suggest that a society’s real constitution is its epistemology: how it decides what counts as real, good, and debatable.
Quote Details
| Topic | Reason & Logic |
|---|
More Quotes by Clive
Add to List









