"Only very slowly and late have men come to realize that unless freedom is universal it is only extended privilege"
About this Quote
Freedom that stops at the edge of your own class is just a nicer name for hierarchy. Hill’s line has the clipped moral clarity of a historian who spent his career watching “liberty” get weaponized by the people already holding the keys. The sentence is built like a trap: it begins with “Only very slowly and late,” a dig at the flattering myth of steady progress, then lands on the real claim - that partial freedom isn’t a stepping-stone to justice, it’s often a barricade against it.
Hill, a Marxist-inflected scholar best known for rethinking the English Revolution, is talking about a recurring pattern in political history: rights are granted first as exemptions, not entitlements. The franchise expands, but property remains a gate. Speech is protected, but dissent is policed. Markets are “free,” but labor isn’t. When freedom is distributed selectively, it functions as social proof that the system is fair while quietly preserving who counts as fully human in practice.
The subtext is accusatory: the ruling order doesn’t merely fail to universalize freedom; it survives by not doing so. “Extended privilege” is a deliberately unromantic phrase, stripping away the romance of constitutional triumph and showing the transaction underneath - a controlled concession to stabilize power.
Read in the 20th-century arc Hill lived through (fascism, decolonization, Cold War liberalism), the warning sharpens: democracies can congratulate themselves on “freedom” while outsourcing coercion, inequality, and unfreedom to the margins. Hill’s intent is to make that self-congratulation impossible.
Hill, a Marxist-inflected scholar best known for rethinking the English Revolution, is talking about a recurring pattern in political history: rights are granted first as exemptions, not entitlements. The franchise expands, but property remains a gate. Speech is protected, but dissent is policed. Markets are “free,” but labor isn’t. When freedom is distributed selectively, it functions as social proof that the system is fair while quietly preserving who counts as fully human in practice.
The subtext is accusatory: the ruling order doesn’t merely fail to universalize freedom; it survives by not doing so. “Extended privilege” is a deliberately unromantic phrase, stripping away the romance of constitutional triumph and showing the transaction underneath - a controlled concession to stabilize power.
Read in the 20th-century arc Hill lived through (fascism, decolonization, Cold War liberalism), the warning sharpens: democracies can congratulate themselves on “freedom” while outsourcing coercion, inequality, and unfreedom to the margins. Hill’s intent is to make that self-congratulation impossible.
Quote Details
| Topic | Freedom |
|---|
More Quotes by John
Add to List







