"Opinions are a private matter. The public has an interest only in judgments"
About this Quote
Benjamin draws a hard line that feels almost rude in its clarity: keep your opinions to yourself; show your judgments. Coming from a critic who lived through Weimar spectacle, mass newspapers, and the early machinery of propaganda, the distinction is less etiquette than survival. Opinion is mood dressed up as principle. It’s the cheap currency of the café and the column, easy to mint, impossible to audit. Judgment, by contrast, is a public act because it carries reasons, consequences, and standards that can be contested. It’s legible.
The subtext is an argument about responsibility in modern media. “Private matter” doesn’t mean opinions are harmless; it means they’re unaccountable. They float free of evidence, and that weightlessness is precisely what makes them so usable by markets and politics. Benjamin’s broader project was to understand how culture becomes reproducible, distributable, and therefore manipulable. In that environment, opinion is the perfect commodity: instantly shareable, instantly replaceable, and strangely immune to correction because it’s framed as personal identity.
Judgment demands friction. It forces the critic (and the reader) to disclose criteria: What are you measuring this against? What do you think art, politics, or a life is for? Benjamin’s line also needles the modern habit of equating expression with contribution. The public doesn’t need more unprocessed takes; it needs decisions that can be argued with, revised, or rejected. In an age that confuses visibility with value, he’s insisting on a more adult form of speech: one that risks being wrong for reasons, not just loud by preference.
The subtext is an argument about responsibility in modern media. “Private matter” doesn’t mean opinions are harmless; it means they’re unaccountable. They float free of evidence, and that weightlessness is precisely what makes them so usable by markets and politics. Benjamin’s broader project was to understand how culture becomes reproducible, distributable, and therefore manipulable. In that environment, opinion is the perfect commodity: instantly shareable, instantly replaceable, and strangely immune to correction because it’s framed as personal identity.
Judgment demands friction. It forces the critic (and the reader) to disclose criteria: What are you measuring this against? What do you think art, politics, or a life is for? Benjamin’s line also needles the modern habit of equating expression with contribution. The public doesn’t need more unprocessed takes; it needs decisions that can be argued with, revised, or rejected. In an age that confuses visibility with value, he’s insisting on a more adult form of speech: one that risks being wrong for reasons, not just loud by preference.
Quote Details
| Topic | Justice |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Walter
Add to List



