"Optimism with some experience behind it is much more energizing than plain old experience with a certain degree of cynicism"
About this Quote
Twyla Tharp isn’t selling feel-good positivity here; she’s describing a working dancer’s fuel. “Optimism with some experience behind it” is not naïveté in a leotard. It’s optimism that has been stress-tested: the kind that’s survived injury, flop nights, bad notes, and the slow, unglamorous repetition that actually builds a career. In Tharp’s world, optimism isn’t a personality trait. It’s a discipline, almost a technique.
The sentence is engineered as a contrast between two kinds of credibility. Experience can certify you in two opposite directions: toward momentum or toward a sour, self-protective knowingness. Tharp names the trap performers slip into as they age in the industry: you collect enough evidence that things can go wrong, and cynicism starts to masquerade as sophistication. It feels smart to predict disappointment; it also quietly drains your willingness to risk looking foolish, which is lethal in any art that requires constant reinvention.
“Plain old experience” is a pointed phrase. It demotes mere longevity, the resume without the spark. By adding “some” before experience, she signals that you don’t need total mastery to be energized; you need just enough real-world proof that effort can convert into outcome. The subtext is practical and slightly ruthless: cynicism is an energy tax, and artists already operate on tight margins. Optimism, when earned, becomes a renewable resource.
The sentence is engineered as a contrast between two kinds of credibility. Experience can certify you in two opposite directions: toward momentum or toward a sour, self-protective knowingness. Tharp names the trap performers slip into as they age in the industry: you collect enough evidence that things can go wrong, and cynicism starts to masquerade as sophistication. It feels smart to predict disappointment; it also quietly drains your willingness to risk looking foolish, which is lethal in any art that requires constant reinvention.
“Plain old experience” is a pointed phrase. It demotes mere longevity, the resume without the spark. By adding “some” before experience, she signals that you don’t need total mastery to be energized; you need just enough real-world proof that effort can convert into outcome. The subtext is practical and slightly ruthless: cynicism is an energy tax, and artists already operate on tight margins. Optimism, when earned, becomes a renewable resource.
Quote Details
| Topic | Optimism |
|---|---|
| Source | Attributed to Twyla Tharp — The Creative Habit: Learn It and Use It for Life (2003). Commonly cited as appearing in Tharp’s discussion of creativity and practice. |
More Quotes by Twyla
Add to List




