"Osama bin Laden is going after us to get us out of the region, so he can deal with the regimes that he sees in the region, or replace them with purists"
About this Quote
Scowcroft’s line is a cold splash of realism in an era that often preferred moral melodrama. He frames bin Laden less as a nihilistic terrorist bent on chaos for chaos’s sake and more as a strategist with a political endgame: push the United States out of the Middle East, then reorder local power on “purist” terms. That choice of verb - “going after us” - matters. It implies instrumentality, not obsession. America is a means to an end, the external obstacle whose departure would clear the board for a second, more consequential fight: the internal struggle over legitimacy in Arab states.
The subtext is also a critique of how Washington narrates threats. By emphasizing “the regimes that he sees” and the desire to “replace them,” Scowcroft nods to a foundational tension: U.S. policy has long tied itself to regional governments that militants brand as corrupt, Western-backed, or insufficiently Islamic. In that light, anti-American violence becomes both propaganda and leverage, designed to delegitimize those regimes by association and to provoke U.S. reactions that deepen local resentment.
Contextually, this is Scowcroft at his most Bush-era national security mandarin: wary of grand crusades, attentive to second-order effects, and suspicious of turning a targeted counterterror fight into a region-wide project. “Purists” is pointedly understated - a bureaucratic euphemism for ideological absolutists - but it carries an implied warning: if U.S. power withdraws clumsily or overreaches militarily, it can accelerate the very purification campaign it’s trying to prevent.
The subtext is also a critique of how Washington narrates threats. By emphasizing “the regimes that he sees” and the desire to “replace them,” Scowcroft nods to a foundational tension: U.S. policy has long tied itself to regional governments that militants brand as corrupt, Western-backed, or insufficiently Islamic. In that light, anti-American violence becomes both propaganda and leverage, designed to delegitimize those regimes by association and to provoke U.S. reactions that deepen local resentment.
Contextually, this is Scowcroft at his most Bush-era national security mandarin: wary of grand crusades, attentive to second-order effects, and suspicious of turning a targeted counterterror fight into a region-wide project. “Purists” is pointedly understated - a bureaucratic euphemism for ideological absolutists - but it carries an implied warning: if U.S. power withdraws clumsily or overreaches militarily, it can accelerate the very purification campaign it’s trying to prevent.
Quote Details
| Topic | War |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Brent
Add to List






