"Others are keen to see if natives other than us live better than we do, without heat in pipes, ice in boxes, sunshine in bulbs, music on disks, or images gliding over a pale screen"
About this Quote
Modern convenience gets itemized here like contraband: heat in pipes, ice in boxes, sunshine in bulbs. Maillart’s list has the brisk, almost comic rhythm of a customs form, and that’s the point. She’s not merely cataloging amenities; she’s revealing how quickly “progress” turns into a sensory cocoon so total we forget it was ever optional. The phrase “keen to see” quietly skewers the voyeurism embedded in Western travel writing: the urge to look at “natives other than us” as if they’re a control group in an experiment about happiness.
The subtext is less “primitive life is purer” than “our yardstick is rigged.” By stacking small miracles of infrastructure alongside “music on disks” and “images gliding over a pale screen,” she collapses the boundary between necessities and entertainments. Warmth, preservation, illumination, diversion: the whole pipeline from survival to spectacle. That “pale screen” lands like a premonition, not nostalgia; it makes modernity feel ghostly, mediated, slightly bloodless.
Context matters. Maillart was a 20th-century travel writer who moved through Central Asia and beyond during an era when travel narratives often doubled as moral theater, with the West casting itself as both judge and benefactor. Her sentence resists that smugness. It acknowledges the traveler’s temptation to treat other people’s lives as evidence either for or against modernity, then exposes the real obsession: whether comfort has made us freer, or simply more insulated from the raw textures of living.
The subtext is less “primitive life is purer” than “our yardstick is rigged.” By stacking small miracles of infrastructure alongside “music on disks” and “images gliding over a pale screen,” she collapses the boundary between necessities and entertainments. Warmth, preservation, illumination, diversion: the whole pipeline from survival to spectacle. That “pale screen” lands like a premonition, not nostalgia; it makes modernity feel ghostly, mediated, slightly bloodless.
Context matters. Maillart was a 20th-century travel writer who moved through Central Asia and beyond during an era when travel narratives often doubled as moral theater, with the West casting itself as both judge and benefactor. Her sentence resists that smugness. It acknowledges the traveler’s temptation to treat other people’s lives as evidence either for or against modernity, then exposes the real obsession: whether comfort has made us freer, or simply more insulated from the raw textures of living.
Quote Details
| Topic | Travel |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Ella
Add to List






