"Our family has lived in Iran for 2,500 years, and Iranian Jewry has the long history in that land"
About this Quote
There is a quiet power in staking a claim to time. Katsav’s “2,500 years” isn’t trivia; it’s a political instrument, compressing a contested identity into a single, unimpeachable number. By invoking the depth of Iranian Jewish presence, he reaches for legitimacy that predates modern borders, modern regimes, even the categories that today’s headlines weaponize. The sentence is built to deny the idea that Jews in Iran are an alien graft or merely a modern geopolitical pawn. They are native, old, and therefore harder to dismiss.
The subtext is shaped by Katsav’s own biography: born in Iran, later an Israeli politician and head of state, speaking from the fault line between Iranian national belonging and Jewish peoplehood. The line subtly challenges the binary that dominates Middle East discourse: Iran versus Israel, Muslim versus Jewish, “their” history versus “ours.” It insists that identities overlap, that a Jew can be Iranian not as a loophole but as a historical fact.
Context matters because Iranian Jewry’s endurance has always been precarious: periods of relative coexistence punctuated by discrimination, and after 1979, the added pressure of revolution, the Israel-Iran confrontation, and the suspicion cast on Jews as potential proxies. Katsav’s phrasing is careful and diplomatic - “that land,” not “our country” - signaling both attachment and distance. The intent is to make Iranian Jewish history emotionally undeniable while keeping the argument portable: a reminder to Israelis, Iranians, and outsiders that the region’s human map is older and messier than today’s slogans.
The subtext is shaped by Katsav’s own biography: born in Iran, later an Israeli politician and head of state, speaking from the fault line between Iranian national belonging and Jewish peoplehood. The line subtly challenges the binary that dominates Middle East discourse: Iran versus Israel, Muslim versus Jewish, “their” history versus “ours.” It insists that identities overlap, that a Jew can be Iranian not as a loophole but as a historical fact.
Context matters because Iranian Jewry’s endurance has always been precarious: periods of relative coexistence punctuated by discrimination, and after 1979, the added pressure of revolution, the Israel-Iran confrontation, and the suspicion cast on Jews as potential proxies. Katsav’s phrasing is careful and diplomatic - “that land,” not “our country” - signaling both attachment and distance. The intent is to make Iranian Jewish history emotionally undeniable while keeping the argument portable: a reminder to Israelis, Iranians, and outsiders that the region’s human map is older and messier than today’s slogans.
Quote Details
| Topic | Legacy & Remembrance |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Moshe
Add to List

