"Our first remark on this subject is that the ministry is an office, and not merely a work"
About this Quote
Hodge’s line lands like a rebuke aimed at Protestant modernity before it fully arrives: stop treating clergy as a kind of freelance spiritual labor and remember it is an office - a constituted role with authority, boundaries, and public accountability. The phrasing is legalistic on purpose. “First remark” signals he’s building a case, not offering a warm devotion. “Office” does the heavy lifting: it evokes ordination, succession, responsibility to a church’s standards, and a stability that outlasts the charisma of any one preacher. “Work,” by contrast, suggests tasks, productivity, and the kind of utilitarian logic that can be measured, optimized, or swapped out.
The subtext is a fight over who gets to speak for the church. In Hodge’s 19th-century American context - revivals, denominational competition, and a burgeoning marketplace of religious entrepreneurs - “ministry as work” could justify almost anyone with zeal, a following, and a gift for rhetoric. Calling it an office pushes back: you don’t simply feel called; you are set apart, examined, and authorized. It’s also a defense of institutional continuity at a time when Americans were learning to trust personal experience over inherited structures.
The intent isn’t nostalgia for hierarchy so much as protection against religious individualism’s dark side: doctrinal drift, personality cults, and moral improvisation. Hodge is making a claim about the church as a body politic. If ministry is an office, it can be trusted, criticized, and disciplined. If it’s “merely a work,” it risks becoming a gig.
The subtext is a fight over who gets to speak for the church. In Hodge’s 19th-century American context - revivals, denominational competition, and a burgeoning marketplace of religious entrepreneurs - “ministry as work” could justify almost anyone with zeal, a following, and a gift for rhetoric. Calling it an office pushes back: you don’t simply feel called; you are set apart, examined, and authorized. It’s also a defense of institutional continuity at a time when Americans were learning to trust personal experience over inherited structures.
The intent isn’t nostalgia for hierarchy so much as protection against religious individualism’s dark side: doctrinal drift, personality cults, and moral improvisation. Hodge is making a claim about the church as a body politic. If ministry is an office, it can be trusted, criticized, and disciplined. If it’s “merely a work,” it risks becoming a gig.
Quote Details
| Topic | Faith |
|---|
More Quotes by Charles
Add to List


