"Our frustration is greater when we have much and want more than when we have nothing and want some. We are less dissatisfied when we lack many things than when we seem to lack but one thing"
About this Quote
Hoffer is taking a knife to the luxury problem we hate admitting: abundance doesn’t calm desire, it refines it. When you have nothing, wanting is broad and almost abstract, spread across a whole landscape of needs. When you have plenty, wanting becomes surgical. The “but one thing” starts to glow like a missing tooth in an otherwise perfect smile, and that single absence can hijack the whole story you tell yourself about your life.
The intent isn’t to romanticize poverty. It’s to expose a psychological booby trap of relative deprivation: satisfaction is less about absolute conditions than about the gap between what we think we deserve and what we can point to as still out of reach. “Much and want more” reads like a diagnosis of status anxiety, the kind that thrives in prosperous societies precisely because benchmarks keep shifting upward. You can always find someone with the extra rung: the better job title, the cleaner kitchen, the partner who looks like a lifestyle brand.
The subtext is moral and political without waving a flag. A culture that teaches people to measure themselves by marginal upgrades manufactures chronic agitation. Hoffer, writing in the midcentury U.S., had watched mass movements feed on grievance, and he understood how easily “one thing” can be inflated into destiny: one lost privilege, one perceived slight, one blocked aspiration. The quote works because it turns envy from a petty flaw into a structural condition, showing how comfort can make discontent more precise, more personal, and harder to dislodge.
The intent isn’t to romanticize poverty. It’s to expose a psychological booby trap of relative deprivation: satisfaction is less about absolute conditions than about the gap between what we think we deserve and what we can point to as still out of reach. “Much and want more” reads like a diagnosis of status anxiety, the kind that thrives in prosperous societies precisely because benchmarks keep shifting upward. You can always find someone with the extra rung: the better job title, the cleaner kitchen, the partner who looks like a lifestyle brand.
The subtext is moral and political without waving a flag. A culture that teaches people to measure themselves by marginal upgrades manufactures chronic agitation. Hoffer, writing in the midcentury U.S., had watched mass movements feed on grievance, and he understood how easily “one thing” can be inflated into destiny: one lost privilege, one perceived slight, one blocked aspiration. The quote works because it turns envy from a petty flaw into a structural condition, showing how comfort can make discontent more precise, more personal, and harder to dislodge.
Quote Details
| Topic | Contentment |
|---|
More Quotes by Eric
Add to List
