"Our most intimate friend is not he to whom we show the worst, but the best of our nature"
About this Quote
Intimacy, Hawthorne suggests, isn not built on confession-as-therapy but on aspiration. The line flips a familiar modern script: that closeness is proven by showing someone your messiest self. For Hawthorne, the true test is whether a friendship can hold your best self - the part that strains toward principle, refinement, and restraint - without turning it into performance or punishment.
The intent is quietly corrective. Hawthorne wrote in a culture steeped in Protestant moral scrutiny and public reputation, where the self was always being weighed for hidden stain. His fiction (The Scarlet Letter, "Young Goodman Brown") is obsessed with the corrosive effects of suspicion: when relationships become interrogations, people either hide or harden. Against that backdrop, the quote reads like a bid for a different kind of trust: not the voyeuristic bond of mutual dirt, but a friendship that makes virtue livable.
The subtext is sharper than it looks. Showing someone "the worst" can be easy: it can be a shortcut to absolution, a way to preempt judgment by confessing first, even a subtle demand that the other person validate your self-disgust. Showing "the best", by contrast, risks envy, disbelief, or disappointment. It requires a friend who won not reduce your ideals to hypocrisy the moment you slip.
Hawthorne is also defending the idea that goodness is not naive. In his world, the soul is complicated, and sincerity is fragile. The most intimate friend is the one who can witness your higher nature and still stay - not to worship it, but to help you keep it.
The intent is quietly corrective. Hawthorne wrote in a culture steeped in Protestant moral scrutiny and public reputation, where the self was always being weighed for hidden stain. His fiction (The Scarlet Letter, "Young Goodman Brown") is obsessed with the corrosive effects of suspicion: when relationships become interrogations, people either hide or harden. Against that backdrop, the quote reads like a bid for a different kind of trust: not the voyeuristic bond of mutual dirt, but a friendship that makes virtue livable.
The subtext is sharper than it looks. Showing someone "the worst" can be easy: it can be a shortcut to absolution, a way to preempt judgment by confessing first, even a subtle demand that the other person validate your self-disgust. Showing "the best", by contrast, risks envy, disbelief, or disappointment. It requires a friend who won not reduce your ideals to hypocrisy the moment you slip.
Hawthorne is also defending the idea that goodness is not naive. In his world, the soul is complicated, and sincerity is fragile. The most intimate friend is the one who can witness your higher nature and still stay - not to worship it, but to help you keep it.
Quote Details
| Topic | Best Friend |
|---|
More Quotes by Nathaniel
Add to List












