"Our musical alphabet is poor and illogical"
About this Quote
Varese is taking a swing at the polite fiction that Western music notation is a neutral, universal language. Calling the “musical alphabet” poor and illogical isn’t just cranky modernist posturing; it’s a composer’s way of pointing out that the staff, the note names, the grid of measures and bars were built to serve certain kinds of music - tonal harmony, stable meters, discrete pitches - and they start to buckle the moment sound itself becomes the subject.
The line lands because it frames notation as an alphabet: a set of symbols that doesn’t merely record ideas but shapes what can be thought. If your alphabet can’t comfortably spell noise, density, microtones, sliding pitch, or timbre as structure, then those elements get treated as “effects” instead of material. Varese, obsessed with percussion, sirens, and what he famously called “organized sound,” is essentially arguing that the medium of writing has been mistaken for the medium of listening. The “illogical” part bites harder: music theory often pretends its symbols are rational (C to D to E, tidy subdivisions), yet the lived reality of sound is continuous, messy, and physical.
Context matters: early 20th-century modernism was a pressure-cooker of new technologies (recording, radio, industrial noise) and new musical ambitions. Varese isn’t rejecting tradition for sport; he’s diagnosing a tooling problem. His subtext is a challenge to institutions - conservatories, orchestras, publishers - that enforce the alphabet and, by extension, enforce what counts as “real” music.
The line lands because it frames notation as an alphabet: a set of symbols that doesn’t merely record ideas but shapes what can be thought. If your alphabet can’t comfortably spell noise, density, microtones, sliding pitch, or timbre as structure, then those elements get treated as “effects” instead of material. Varese, obsessed with percussion, sirens, and what he famously called “organized sound,” is essentially arguing that the medium of writing has been mistaken for the medium of listening. The “illogical” part bites harder: music theory often pretends its symbols are rational (C to D to E, tidy subdivisions), yet the lived reality of sound is continuous, messy, and physical.
Context matters: early 20th-century modernism was a pressure-cooker of new technologies (recording, radio, industrial noise) and new musical ambitions. Varese isn’t rejecting tradition for sport; he’s diagnosing a tooling problem. His subtext is a challenge to institutions - conservatories, orchestras, publishers - that enforce the alphabet and, by extension, enforce what counts as “real” music.
Quote Details
| Topic | Music |
|---|
More Quotes by Edgard
Add to List
