"Our prayer and God's mercy are like two buckets in a well; while the one ascends the other descends"
About this Quote
Hopkins turns prayer from a mystical monologue into a piece of everyday mechanics: two buckets counterbalancing each other in a well. It’s a simple image with a quiet bite. Prayer, in this framing, isn’t a way of prying God’s hand open; it’s the human motion that makes room for what’s already there. You pull, the other side moves. The metaphor domesticates the divine without making it trivial, which is exactly why it lands.
The intent is partly pastoral and partly disciplinary, fitting for an educator steeped in 19th-century Protestant moral formation. Hopkins is teaching spiritual causality without promising vending-machine religion. God’s mercy “descends” not because you’ve impressed heaven with eloquence, but because the act of praying puts you in the right relationship to receive it. That’s the subtext: prayer changes the petitioner first. It’s less negotiation than alignment.
At the same time, the image preserves a feeling of reciprocity. You do something; something answers. In an era suspicious of both cold determinism and flashy revivalist emotionalism, the well-and-buckets model offers a middle way: grace is real, agency matters, and neither cancels the other. The well implies depth and hidden supply; mercy isn’t manufactured on demand, it’s drawn from a source beyond sight. The sting is that if you don’t pull, you can’t complain about thirst.
The intent is partly pastoral and partly disciplinary, fitting for an educator steeped in 19th-century Protestant moral formation. Hopkins is teaching spiritual causality without promising vending-machine religion. God’s mercy “descends” not because you’ve impressed heaven with eloquence, but because the act of praying puts you in the right relationship to receive it. That’s the subtext: prayer changes the petitioner first. It’s less negotiation than alignment.
At the same time, the image preserves a feeling of reciprocity. You do something; something answers. In an era suspicious of both cold determinism and flashy revivalist emotionalism, the well-and-buckets model offers a middle way: grace is real, agency matters, and neither cancels the other. The well implies depth and hidden supply; mercy isn’t manufactured on demand, it’s drawn from a source beyond sight. The sting is that if you don’t pull, you can’t complain about thirst.
Quote Details
| Topic | Prayer |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Mark
Add to List











