"Our society must make it right and possible for old people not to fear the young or be deserted by them, for the test of a civilization is the way that it cares for its helpless members"
About this Quote
Buck’s line looks like a gentle moral reminder, but it’s also an indictment disguised as a standard for “civilization.” She doesn’t flatter society; she audits it. By pairing “make it right” with “make it possible,” she refuses the easy out of good intentions. Ethics without infrastructure is just sentiment. The sentence pressures the reader to see elder care not as private family business or charitable extra credit, but as a collective design problem: housing, wages for caregivers, public health, and the social architecture that keeps generations in contact instead of in separate silos.
The sharpest move is the emotional pivot: “old people not to fear the young.” That fear isn’t only about crime or disrespect; it’s the dread of becoming disposable in a culture that worships speed, productivity, and novelty. Buck suggests that when elders fear the young, the problem isn’t youth. It’s a society that trains the young to treat dependence as failure and teaches the old to anticipate abandonment.
Then she lands the verdict: “the test of a civilization.” Not its art, wealth, or military power - its treatment of “helpless members.” The word “helpless” is intentionally uncomfortable, because it collapses the distance we like to keep from vulnerability. Buck, writing in a century marked by depression, war, and mass displacement, knew how quickly “independent” people can become contingent. The subtext is simple and unsparing: your future self is the policy you’re willing to fund today.
The sharpest move is the emotional pivot: “old people not to fear the young.” That fear isn’t only about crime or disrespect; it’s the dread of becoming disposable in a culture that worships speed, productivity, and novelty. Buck suggests that when elders fear the young, the problem isn’t youth. It’s a society that trains the young to treat dependence as failure and teaches the old to anticipate abandonment.
Then she lands the verdict: “the test of a civilization.” Not its art, wealth, or military power - its treatment of “helpless members.” The word “helpless” is intentionally uncomfortable, because it collapses the distance we like to keep from vulnerability. Buck, writing in a century marked by depression, war, and mass displacement, knew how quickly “independent” people can become contingent. The subtext is simple and unsparing: your future self is the policy you’re willing to fund today.
Quote Details
| Topic | Aging |
|---|---|
| Source | Help us find the source |
More Quotes by Pearl
Add to List










