"Our systems, perhaps, are nothing more than an unconscious apology for our faults, a gigantic scaffolding whose object is to hide from us our favorite sin"
About this Quote
A system is supposed to be a triumph of reason: clean lines, clear rules, the promise that if you follow the method you can outrun your own messiness. Amiel flips that comforting story into an indictment. The real function of “our systems,” he suggests, is psychological, not intellectual: an “unconscious apology” that lets us keep our flaws while feeling absolved of them. The word “apology” carries its older sense of defense, a lawyerly brief for the self. We don’t merely err; we build an argument to make the error look inevitable, even virtuous.
The metaphor does the heavy lifting. Scaffolding isn’t a building; it’s a temporary structure that enables construction while obscuring what’s underneath. Amiel’s twist is that we’re not constructing a cathedral of truth, we’re erecting a screen. The “gigantic” scale matters: rationalization isn’t a small, private habit but something we inflate into institutions, ideologies, bureaucracies, moral codes. Systems become architecture for denial.
Then comes the stinger: “our favorite sin.” Not just a fault, not a one-off mistake, but the indulgence we return to and curate. Amiel’s subtext is that people don’t primarily use ideas to discover; they use them to protect what they already want to keep doing. In the 19th-century climate of grand theories and moral earnestness, his line reads like an early warning against the era’s confidence: the sharper your framework, the easier it is to hide the one thing you refuse to change.
The metaphor does the heavy lifting. Scaffolding isn’t a building; it’s a temporary structure that enables construction while obscuring what’s underneath. Amiel’s twist is that we’re not constructing a cathedral of truth, we’re erecting a screen. The “gigantic” scale matters: rationalization isn’t a small, private habit but something we inflate into institutions, ideologies, bureaucracies, moral codes. Systems become architecture for denial.
Then comes the stinger: “our favorite sin.” Not just a fault, not a one-off mistake, but the indulgence we return to and curate. Amiel’s subtext is that people don’t primarily use ideas to discover; they use them to protect what they already want to keep doing. In the 19th-century climate of grand theories and moral earnestness, his line reads like an early warning against the era’s confidence: the sharper your framework, the easier it is to hide the one thing you refuse to change.
Quote Details
| Topic | Ethics & Morality |
|---|
More Quotes by Henri
Add to List









