"Out of timber so crooked as that from which man is made nothing entirely straight can be carved"
About this Quote
Kant’s line is a bracing refusal of utopian fantasies: if you want a flawless moral order, you’ve picked the wrong raw material. “Timber so crooked” turns human nature into a carpentry problem, and the craftsmanship metaphor does two sly things at once. It demystifies lofty political ideals (institutions are built, not bestowed), and it lowers our expectations just enough to make responsibility unavoidable. You can’t blame the blueprint when the wood fights back; you also can’t pretend the wood is innocent.
The intent isn’t misanthropy so much as anti-innocence. Kant is warning reformers and rulers that coercive schemes designed to “straighten” people will either snap them or splinter society. The subtext: every project of perfectibility hides a temptation toward cruelty, because perfection becomes a pretext for forcing the irregular human into a rigid shape. Crookedness here isn’t merely vice; it’s the stubborn mix of self-interest, frailty, and partiality that makes ethics necessary in the first place.
Context matters. Kant writes in the Enlightenment, amid rising faith in reason, progress, and rational administration. His political thought tries to thread a needle: build structures that anticipate human weakness without surrendering to it. That’s why the metaphor lands so well: it’s tactile, almost workshop-common, but it underwrites a sophisticated claim about limits. The best we can “carve” is not moral purity but workable forms - laws, norms, checks and balances - that aim at justice while assuming the material will never be straight.
The intent isn’t misanthropy so much as anti-innocence. Kant is warning reformers and rulers that coercive schemes designed to “straighten” people will either snap them or splinter society. The subtext: every project of perfectibility hides a temptation toward cruelty, because perfection becomes a pretext for forcing the irregular human into a rigid shape. Crookedness here isn’t merely vice; it’s the stubborn mix of self-interest, frailty, and partiality that makes ethics necessary in the first place.
Context matters. Kant writes in the Enlightenment, amid rising faith in reason, progress, and rational administration. His political thought tries to thread a needle: build structures that anticipate human weakness without surrendering to it. That’s why the metaphor lands so well: it’s tactile, almost workshop-common, but it underwrites a sophisticated claim about limits. The best we can “carve” is not moral purity but workable forms - laws, norms, checks and balances - that aim at justice while assuming the material will never be straight.
Quote Details
| Topic | Wisdom |
|---|---|
| Source | Immanuel Kant, "Idea for a Universal History with a Cosmopolitan Purpose" (1784). Original German: "Aus so krummem Holze, als woraus der Mensch gemacht ist, kann nichts ganz Gerades gezimmert werden." (commonly rendered in English as in your query) |
More Quotes by Immanuel
Add to List








