"Party action should follow, not precede the creation of a dominant popular sentiment"
About this Quote
Foster’s line is a cold splash of realism for anyone addicted to the romance of “movement first, mandate later.” She’s arguing that parties don’t get to conjure legitimacy out of strategy meetings and ballot lines; they’re supposed to be downstream from something messier and broader: a public mood strong enough to discipline the party, not the other way around. The key word is “dominant.” Not a loud faction, not a trending outrage cycle, but a sentiment with gravitational pull - one that makes officeholders and operatives nervous to ignore.
The intent is tactical and moral at once. Tactically, she’s warning activists and reformers against mistaking organizational energy for social power. A party can win a skirmish with clever messaging, but if the underlying sentiment isn’t settled, victory is brittle: it collapses at the next backlash, midterm, or media pivot. Morally, she’s sketching a theory of democratic legitimacy: parties are instruments, not authors, of the people’s will. That’s a direct critique of machine politics and elite brokerage, where party leaders manufacture platforms and then shop them to voters like finished products.
The subtext lands on a familiar American tension: grassroots agitation versus institutional capture. Foster, as an activist, is implicitly locating the real work before the ballot - in persuasion, coalition-building, and shifting what “common sense” even is. Only after that cultural and civic ground has moved does “party action” become something other than theatrical ambition.
The intent is tactical and moral at once. Tactically, she’s warning activists and reformers against mistaking organizational energy for social power. A party can win a skirmish with clever messaging, but if the underlying sentiment isn’t settled, victory is brittle: it collapses at the next backlash, midterm, or media pivot. Morally, she’s sketching a theory of democratic legitimacy: parties are instruments, not authors, of the people’s will. That’s a direct critique of machine politics and elite brokerage, where party leaders manufacture platforms and then shop them to voters like finished products.
The subtext lands on a familiar American tension: grassroots agitation versus institutional capture. Foster, as an activist, is implicitly locating the real work before the ballot - in persuasion, coalition-building, and shifting what “common sense” even is. Only after that cultural and civic ground has moved does “party action” become something other than theatrical ambition.
Quote Details
| Topic | Vision & Strategy |
|---|
More Quotes by Judith
Add to List




